Judd to selwood?

[dicey7]

I know that its not advised to do a sideways trade from a prem to a prem but i sorta feel this could be an exception

Ill have to eventually trade judd out anyway for the Rd 23 game in finals, so im thinking about bringing J.selwood in i know he has Rd 22 bye but im prety confident that ill win my first final and have that week off.

I feel judd maybe be playing with pain over the next few weeks im sure he will play through it but it will affect his scores? he consistently scores around 100 but not much over 120, while J selwood has the capability of doing those 120+ scores, also Selwood is against GC this week and can tear it up.

what are you thoughts? cheers

[Problems]

Has the team announced anything definitive on his injury and how long he'll be out for yet?

[hardnut]

".....its not advised to do a sideways trade from a prem to a prem"

unless there is strong evidence something s wrong with Judd then this is a terrible trade especially given this far out how sure can you be of winning your 1st final really...Get Selwood another way

[Chopps]

you're also not achieving much finals wise as rd 23 by becomes rd22 bye with selwood

[antonc]

Def no for me.
If you have to do it after rnd 22 or like hardnut said another way

[LaHug]

I would have to say that is the perfect trade... after round 22.