Question hour- Get Ziplocked

[Ziplock]

So, Ya'll have until 5.30 to ask me questions. My answers may be sporadic, as I am at work, but I leave at 5.30 for my 1.5 hr commute home, so, get cracking all, I'll answer as best as I can.

:-X

[bomberboy0618]

First of all are you a scer and a dter or just a dter?

[Montag]

Do i keep a.swallow and jack redden?
do i need bench cover this week. mids are pendles, selwood, redden, a.swallow, gibbs, libba no cover?
should i trade brodie smith to suckling???
do you like minge?

[Ziplock]

DTer atm, I got into it through some friends when I was at school, and subsequently I play mainly for our league. I am considering going into SC next year though. If you have a SC question though, and want just a completely detached opinion, I can look up some past stats and number crunch it out for you though?

[bomberboy0618]

I am an scer but i want an opinion.
Were curnow-hibberd and toy-shaw good trades?

[Montag]

Please help me zip

[Ziplock]

Do i keep a.swallow and jack redden?
do i need bench cover this week. mids are pendles, selwood, redden, a.swallow, gibbs, libba no cover?
should i trade brodie smith to suckling???
do you like minge?

Well, if you started with redden, you could consider trading him out, however if you jumped on that bandwagon, IMO you should give him at least one more week. Do you have dpp available that could cover your mids (you'd be surprised how often it's over looked). But, personally, I've gone into a few games this year with no bench cover and come out fine, very few players in your mids would be subjected to a late withdrawal baring a freak einjury, and none of them are prone anyway.

If you can afford to make the b smith trade, I would do it. Suckling looks good, and his monster score's can't be ignored, while smith is going to take weeks to make up for lost money and then make money- he's a CC not a keeper.

The A swallow dilemma is facing all his owners. I say keep him, he should come good and he's a very good players, he just hasn't properly adjusted to the amount of attention he's been keeping. That being said, if he hasn't improved by his matchup against collingwood, you should consider dropping him then, as someone else on this forum mentioned, he has an easy run until then, and if he can't improve by then no point keeping him.

[Nails]

You say you're at work... What do you do for work?

[bomberboy0618]

DT ;D

[Montag]

thanks zip but you didnt say wether you like the minge ;D.
got redden 3 weeks ago. want to trade to mundy but they are playing north this week?
who will score more mundy or redden

[Ziplock]

I am an scer but i want an opinion.
Were curnow-hibberd and toy-shaw good trades?

I would say the curnow- hibberd was, as he's injured for quite some weeks, and mighten't even return to his prior scoring potential after injury, coupled with his BE. While hibberd is on the bubble, and has a -50 odd BE, solid trade especially with the dpp link

toy- may have been a bit premature, he still has a low BE compared to his average, but that being said, shaw is absolutely flogging it.

In the long run, should your players keep up, those trades will have been worth it. If Shaw returns to his inconsistency though, you may have taken a small loss.

[bomberboy0618]

Thanks man 8)
Will Jono Brown ever be a viable upgrade?

[Ziplock]

thanks zip but you didnt say wether you like the minge ;D.
got redden 3 weeks ago. want to trade to mundy but they are playing north this week?
who will score more mundy or redden

Honestly, probably mundy, but redden could lift, might just been on a downer... for instance swan and pendles have both been scoring down, doesn't mean you'd trade them out :) I would give him another week.

[sammy]

what do you think of Stanley to Hibberd and then Tapscott to Goodes?

[Ziplock]

You say you're at work... What do you do for work?

I work at an IT company casually, I'm filling in for someone for 2 months lol.