isaac smith

[Stocutz]

whats peoples thoughts on him?

i thought he looked good but maybe rioli has taken his spot? he was a 1st rd draft pick so obviusly the hawks rate him.

just not sure who hes gonna come back in for?

[Holz]

if you have him good luck, but if you were planning on getting him in get in mzungu instead as its clear he will play (just dont put him on your field) and than get in smith when/if he returns. If he comes back when cyril is inthe team than i think his JS should be reasonably good.

[Stocutz]

dont have him, was going to downgrade matera to him.

Mzunga seem all the rage, i hope he lives up to the hype. might just have to punt on him.

[Holz]

dont have him, was going to downgrade matera to him.

Mzunga seem all the rage, i hope he lives up to the hype. might just have to punt on him.

he will live up to it eventually just dont expect him to start socring well for a few more weeks

[Stocutz]

dont have him, was going to downgrade matera to him.

Mzunga seem all the rage, i hope he lives up to the hype. might just have to punt on him.

he will live up to it eventually just dont expect him to start socring well for a few more weeks

thats will be fine, he will be my 10th fwd so no issue in the short term. i may even get him next week for matera

[LEV]

i pulled the trigger finger a little early this week and got him in, only to see last night that he isn't playing (stoopid me, worst thing you can do in DT is not wait!).

may aswell hold off this week and see what happens after this round.  His MPP is handy.

I think he'll get a fair amount of games (my opinion based on nothing!)

[FLOPITOUT1]

Another victim of general soreness. Id say he's just knackered from his first 2 games think he played the whole game last week becuase of the 2 early injuries. No need to worry just yet

[elephants]

bought him in after i saw he was out. he doesnt need to play for me he's my 10th forward and yeah his mpp is good too.

[lukedogg17]

hate him, do not rate this guy at all. cant believe how uncoordinated he looks when he plays. hope he never plays afl again lol

but seriously, youd think he'd struggle to make it back into the side now that cyrils back.

general soreness could be the hawks way of saying thanks for covering for cyril, you werent terrible so we'll be nice and not omit you.

[FLOPITOUT1]

hate him, do not rate this guy at all. cant believe how uncoordinated he looks when he plays. hope he never plays afl again lol

but seriously, youd think he'd struggle to make it back into the side now that cyrils back.

general soreness could be the hawks way of saying thanks for covering for cyril, you werent terrible so we'll be nice and not omit you.

Very harsh words you know him personally yeah ?

[MissPiesFF]

59 and 89 are not bad scores for his first ditch effort. And scores mean nothing when it comes to Clarkey choosing his team. i wouldn't rule him out just yet. We all need to give our rooks some time to find their feet, well unless you are a Barlow and rip it up first go and all season.

[Ziplock]

lol, I thought that was a little harsh as well. When you say looks uncoordinated, do you mean plays uncoordinated, or just  looks gumpy, because honestly I don't see an issue if he still plays well but is all legs and arms.

Although that could be my own personal bias coming through-- as that's how I've played all sports :P

[MissPiesFF]

lol, I thought that was a little harsh as well. When you say looks uncoordinated, do you mean plays uncoordinated, or just  looks gumpy, because honestly I don't see an issue if he still plays well but is all legs and arms.

Although that could be my own personal bias coming through-- as that's how I've played all sports :P

Indeed Zip, when I watch Sandi play he looks so 'gumpy' ha

[yorgis]

yeah agreed he palyed well enough to hold his spot, but with cyril back i guess it was an opportunity to rest him. could of at least played another game to get his price rise. mzungu played extremely well in nab cup and looked to be another barlow. he did his knee and it may just take him a few games to get back into it. he and smith will be very valuable mpp's

[Ziplock]

^ I did call it that smith would be dropped with rioli's return. Just sayin' :P