Smith or Lower

[Alka]

B. Smith named as center, better average than Lower discounting last weeks sub.
Lower, up against a weaker side.

My other defenders this week: Deledio, Gibbs, Adcock, Scotland, Puopolo, Hibberd.

[hardnut]

tough call, probably Lower just to avoid starting as sub role - surely Mzungu will wear the green vest? Lower could get the red one though...

[dale93]

Wow very week defence...why dont you do a double trade and dowgrade on and upgrade the other one with the cash to Shaw or maybe even the gods....you shouldnt have 3 rookies starting at this point of the year.

[FLOPITOUT1]

tough call, probably Lower just to avoid starting as sub role - surely Mzungu will wear the green vest? Lower could get the red one though...

+ 1

[Jizberts]

Wow very week defence...why dont you do a double trade and dowgrade on and upgrade the other one with the cash to Shaw or maybe even the gods....you shouldnt have 3 rookies starting at this point of the year.

hes not asking you to rate his team his asking who to start. i will be starting lower out of smith, duigan and puopolo

[Montag]

that isn't weak dfence. it is quite good.
Deledio, Gibbs, Adcock, Scotland, are all premos and he can upgrade to enright in next couple weeks when he drops but not yet

Heppel is missing but he might be in mids????

i have
deledio, gibbs, heppel, rawlings, duigan, lower, hibberd

[Ziplock]

3 rookies in a position by round 9 is weak... Personally, my weakest position is my mids where (this week) I have to play 1 dpp fwd (higgins), as well as two mid pricers (cotchin and ward)

With a defence like that, I'm guessing you're probably carrying a relatively completed fwd line, and a midfield with swan, boyd, selwood, pendles etc.?

[Alka]

My def isn't great, but I've made a decision to focus elsewhere, and with the lack of consistent "premo" defenders I'm not too unhappy. Starting with Duffield didn't help, but turning him into Scotland is looking good so far - pretty happy with this week :).

Anyway thanks Jizberts, this post was just about who to start, mentioned the rest in case you figured both were better than one of the others. Lower starting now. Fingers crossed!

[MissPiesFF]

that isn't weak dfence. it is quite good.
Deledio, Gibbs, Adcock, Scotland, are all premos and he can upgrade to enright in next couple weeks when he drops but not yet

Heppel is missing but he might be in mids????

i have
deledio, gibbs, heppel, rawlings, duigan, lower, hibberd

+1 I was thinking the same thing Montag, I've got
Lids, Gibbs, Heppell, Murphy, Buckley, Hibberd, J.OBrien,Trengove(port), B.Smith, Marcovic not in any particular order.
Now THIS ^^^is what you call a weak Backline.