Two final questions before lockout.

jvalles · May 20, 2011, 11:42:33 AM

Q1: My mid line - Swan, Boyd, Selwood, A.Swallow, Liberatore, Atley

Which mid should I trade Atley for: Montagna, Murphy or Mundy (Mitchell, Ablett, Rischetelli & Pendlebury are on the cards for next weeks trade)?

Q2: Who to play on the field out of:
- Knights at HFF against Pies
- Darling @ home against Dogs
- Tapscott on the wing against Saints

Leaning towards Knights out of price & ave, but think Tapscott could be a smoky on the wing.

yorgis · May 20, 2011, 11:54:27 AM

mundy and darling

Fireballz · May 20, 2011, 11:58:06 AM

I say Montags and Darling

AlexIsOnFire · May 20, 2011, 11:59:27 AM

Murphs fresh off the bye,

And I think Tappy should prove all the critics wrong this week. I cant wait to see him on the wing if it stays like that, plenty of tackles, marks and a booming left kick.

jvalles · May 20, 2011, 12:40:31 PM

So...looking like a split decision at this stage!

I like the look of Murphy, but worried about his bye in the finals. Mundy I feel may get the tag of Cornes with all of Freo out with injury. Leaning on Montags coz I think he has a shot at making his BE this week of 144.

Nails · May 20, 2011, 12:52:22 PM

Quote from: jvalles on May 20, 2011, 12:40:31 PM
So...looking like a split decision at this stage!

I like the look of Murphy, but worried about his bye in the finals. Mundy I feel may get the tag of Cornes with all of Freo out with injury. Leaning on Montags coz I think he has a shot at making his BE this week of 144.

Mundy gets tagged every week because he's their best player. He still knocks out consistent tons though.

Out of the players in question Mundy is an easy choice. He had a poor rd 1 like a lot of players like Boyd, took him a bit to warm into the season but since rd 2 has averaged 117. Mundy will be top 6 midfielders come years end, Murphy and Montag won't be.

jvalles · May 20, 2011, 12:56:52 PM

Quote from: Nails on May 20, 2011, 12:52:22 PM
Quote from: jvalles on May 20, 2011, 12:40:31 PM
So...looking like a split decision at this stage!

I like the look of Murphy, but worried about his bye in the finals. Mundy I feel may get the tag of Cornes with all of Freo out with injury. Leaning on Montags coz I think he has a shot at making his BE this week of 144.

Mundy gets tagged every week because he's their best player. He still knocks out consistent tons though.

Out of the players in question Mundy is an easy choice. He had a poor rd 1 like a lot of players like Boyd, took him a bit to warm into the season but since rd 2 has averaged 117. Mundy will be top 6 midfielders come years end, Murphy and Montag won't be.

Thanks for the input, I've been leaning on Mundy for weeks till now with Murphy and Tags, but if I get Mundy before his price increases, then I can see how Murph and Tags do this week along with the others I am targeting.

yorgis · May 20, 2011, 01:01:35 PM

mundy's free for finals [ no byes ]

remon tea · May 20, 2011, 01:27:18 PM

Mundy + Darling for sure. Even if darling doesn't kick goals he still tackles and racks up good points. Plus Stephen Hill is usually the one who gets tagged, although this week Pav might cop the tag if he plays midfield.. :)

bundyboy · May 20, 2011, 02:02:05 PM

mundy and darling my vote too....

mundy just proving to be a consistent gun...and darling a step ahead of your other choices I recon.. incredibly mobile and fast for such a big guy - and even if he doesn't kick a bag..he marks plenty up the ground and tackles well..

montagna - cheap as...but I can't bring myself to recommend any stkilda player any more.. :'(

jvalles · May 20, 2011, 02:11:09 PM

Quote from: bundyboy on May 20, 2011, 02:02:05 PM
mundy and darling my vote too....

mundy just proving to be a consistent gun...and darling a step ahead of your other choices I recon.. incredibly mobile and fast for such a big guy - and even if he doesn't kick a bag..he marks plenty up the ground and tackles well..

montagna - cheap as...but I can't bring myself to recommend any stkilda player any more.. :'(

Good work fellas, you've given me great feedback. I will wait 1 more week with Montagna, Saints have to come good at some point don't they?

Memphistopheles · May 20, 2011, 02:16:13 PM

Quote from: jvalles on May 20, 2011, 02:11:09 PM
Quote from: bundyboy on May 20, 2011, 02:02:05 PM
mundy and darling my vote too....

mundy just proving to be a consistent gun...and darling a step ahead of your other choices I recon.. incredibly mobile and fast for such a big guy - and even if he doesn't kick a bag..he marks plenty up the ground and tackles well..

montagna - cheap as...but I can't bring myself to recommend any stkilda player any more.. :'(

Good work fellas, you've given me great feedback. I will wait 1 more week with Montagna, Saints have to come good at some point don't they?

No quite frankly i think St Kilda will miss out on the 8 this year.

Doesn't mean Tags won't be a good pick-up - lots of people have Rocky and Redden and the Lions are rubbish.

I think you should get Mundy and play Knights.