VERY CONFUSED!!!!!!.....Expert advice needed

[nostradamus]

Am tossing up who to trade out B.Smith or Otten

Otten has a low BE, has more cash to make and should be playing soon

Smith is playing, has high BE but seems to have reasonablle (??) JS

What do u think fellas?

[jvalles]

You got Smith as a cash cow, he has peaked, time to lose him.  I will be moving him on this week, he has done his job.

[nostradamus]

You got Smith as a cash cow, he has peaked, time to lose him.  I will be moving him on this week, he has done his job.

Do tend to agree with u, but its disappointing he didnt moo a bit louder

....am still unsure who has the better JS out of them  :-\

[Chopps]

Brodie Smith needs to be axed

[fortynine]

Keep ottens, he'll be back soon I believe

[Chichos]

I would keep Brodie Smith as he is a number 14 draft pick. He has been inconsistent this year in dream team but you have to pick him over Andy Otten as Brodie is capable of high scores.

[Bluke]

Ottens hasnt peaked. He'll come back soon.

Smith has done his dash.

[MissPiesFF]

You are all nuts! Brodie will shine V's pies, Otten well...We've all been there done that over recent years in DT jumped on the Otten train only to have him stop at every god damn station except Richmond to get to the G!!!!

PS. The only reason he scored 11 is cus he subbed....der. Imagine with much more TOG he will get over his B/E easily after a few rounds and will make his cash back and then some.

[nostradamus]

still bloody unsure......there are good arguements for and against both  ???

......am thinkin it might just come down to a "go with my gut" solution

but am really wanting to get puopolo and hibberd......aaaahhhhhhhh!!!!!!!