Long term M7: Harris v Libba poll

Started by Carn, May 19, 2011, 10:08:18 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who should you keep as your 7th mid as cover for the year?

Harris
16 (55.2%)
Libba
13 (44.8%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Carn

Harris has injury concerns?
Libba job security issues?

Carn

Current mid/def:

Goddard, Gibbs, Deledio, Adcock, Heppell, Lower, L.Thompson
(D.Stanley, Pedersen, Jacobs)

Swan, Judd, Montagna, Bartel, Selwood, Harris
(Liberatore, Bewick, Hibberd)

Need to free up some serious cash to get shaw in for Thompson so it's either Harris or libba.

Blairholt

Quote from: Carn on May 19, 2011, 10:08:18 PM
Harris has injury concerns?
Libba job security issues?
so true harris is having problems with injures while libba is young and averaging 91 i'd keep libba. i had to make the same desision last week.

Sammocorw


Capper

Quote from: Carn on May 19, 2011, 10:08:18 PM
Harris has injury concerns?
Libba job security issues?


What injury concerns??? Harris missed last week because his grandfather died.

I am looking at having Harris/Swallow and Liba as M8 and M9 and upgrading Swallow/Harris in the next couple of week

bluedreamin

Harris was listed as having a hip injury. That's the first I have heard about a grandfather...

Capper

Quote from: bluedreamin on May 19, 2011, 10:38:00 PM
Harris was listed as having a hip injury. That's the first I have heard about a grandfather...

M0nty mentioned it last night during the coaches box

Carn

I just heard about the hip injury.

Very close in the poll!

charliesheen

probably going to get rid of both harris and swallow and liba,

will probably be Iles at this stage, but that may change.

diddley

i really am honestly considering this myself. so damn hard. flip of a coin really.

thebrock7

Quote from: charliesheen on May 19, 2011, 11:36:56 PM
probably going to get rid of both harris and swallow and liba,

will probably be Iles at this stage, but that may change.

I got Iles in on the bubble for this purpose but will wait and see later in the season.

I think Libba for me, don't think JS is an issue maybe more fatigue of a young player, with the new sub rule etc. I still chose Libba above but I could see the benefit that Harris is unlikely be/get subbed.

charliesheen

Harris's hip is a bit of a concern.  I really just need someone for cover, don't really need them to average 80's.

thebrock7

I'm just looking again at my side and I actually think that Conca could quite easily be the best option for me in regards to long term cover

charliesheen

Quote from: thebrock7 on May 20, 2011, 12:37:10 AM
I'm just looking again at my side and I actually think that Conca could quite easily be the best option for me in regards to long term cover

richmond still have 2 byes to go.  and one of them is a multi round bye.

Marstar

There is a thing called MPP. You dont need a 7th. Sell them all ;)