Dion Prestia?

[3.votes]

Hey what should i do with Prestia?

I can hold him for one more week to hope he gets named with a low B/E still, meaning my trades this week will be:

OPTION 1
Bewick to Jacobs
Swallow to Scotland (who next week ill sub back to my defence)

or i can trade him and do this get Mundy:

OPTION 2
Prestia to Mzungu
Swallow to Mundy

Thoughts?

[3.votes]

Team: Rocket Science

Backs
Gibbs, Goddard, Rawlings, Deledio, Heppell, Duigan, Puopolo (Lower, Hibberd, Stanley)

Mids
Swan, Pendlebury, Boyd, Selwood, Higgins, Krakouer (Swallow, Harris, Bewick)

Rucks
Cox, Sandilands (McCauley, Smith)

Fwds
Sylvia, Fyfe, N.Reiwoldt, Franklin, S.Johnson, Knights, Darling (Matera, Prestia, Harper)

Gives an idea of the situation at hand.

[3.votes]

Do you think Prestia will return the following week?

If not then may aswell get Mundy basicly.

[Fenno]

to be honest I don't like either of the trades. Prestia will be back and him and Bewick haven't made enough cash yet. Just not worth the trade. surely you have some rookies in your side that have peaked in price that you can trade instead. Trade Duigan, Harris even Matera to make the cash needed before you trade Prestia or Bewick

[Problems]

Prestia made the trip to Adelaide last week as an emergency so have some faith in him.

[3.votes]

Matera and Harris still have some cash to make, more so than Bewick.
Duigan is ready to go but i rekn heel score ok against the Cattery.

Im not convinced on Prestia's return but if i trade him it lets me get Mundy.

[Fenno]

don't let breakevens be your only guide on how much a player has to make. if bewick knocks out two 70s in his next two games all of a sudden he has a tiny break even and is on his way to 200k+. You could say Harris will make it to about 280k and Bewick say 220k that would mean Bewick has made 25k more than harris right now. I have both Bewick and harris and I tell you now Bewick will be hanging around while Harris is getting the chop.

[3.votes]

point taken.

i can see where your coming from.

so you think it would be a better move to go

Duigan to Jacobs (and start Hibberd on field)
Swallow to Mundy

i think Duigan can go alright against the cats...

[Fenno]

Much better trade. I think Hibberd and Duigan will score very similar this week maybe 10pts difference max.