Double Down or Down Up

[Bluke]

Two strategies, which would you do?

Week 1
Duigan -> Hibberd
Lower -> Puopolo

Week 2
Swallow -> Gun
Krakouer/Libba -> Gun

or

Week 1
Lower -> Puopolo/Hibberd
Swallow -> Mundy

Week 2
Tapscott -> Lynch/Smith
Krakouer/Libba -> Gun

Which player would you bring in Hibberd or Poo?
Which player would you trade out Duigan or Lower?

[TMurphBROWNLOW]

gain an extra 50 points or so and climb up the rankings :) mundy is a very good choice.

[Bluke]

Yea, trying to decide if both Hibberd and Puopolo are the type of players you just dont want to miss.

[jeffbutch]

2nd scenario

[TMurphBROWNLOW]

im missing out on hibberd because if you look at the essendon's OUTS, they wont be out for long and you'd expect hibberd to be the first to go. he looks like their weakest link unfortunately.

[dicey7]

2nd scenario where you get mundy and a another gun in

Plus i feel lynch will be good bench cover

[C-Dogg]

im missing out on hibberd because if you look at the essendon's OUTS, they wont be out for long and you'd expect hibberd to be the first to go. he looks like their weakest link unfortunately.

x2

[Bluke]

Okay, was thinking the same thing in regards to Hibberds JS. Poo poo it is.

But..

Who goes out of Stanley, Lower or Duigan then?

[TMurphBROWNLOW]

So who goes out of Stanley, Lower or Duigan then?

lower. don't be distracted by him being named in the middle! stanley has a lot of upside and some people are naming him as a keeper, and duigan is still on the rise. lower looks to be your only option.

[Bluke]

Yea I guess.. theres also the Old Club syndrome...

Some players cut it up against their old club (unless your Krakouer lol).

[The Grundles]

I have been contemplating this all one all week!  Here is where my current train of thought lies...

If you have the money for a gun...invest! They are guns for a reason and will give you great returns week in week out.

I WAS thinking of the following trades

Grimes -> Puopolo
Foley -> Hibberd/Smith (was leaning towards Smith but he has been left out due to soreness)

but now I am thinking:

Grimes -> Puopolo
Foley -> Boyd

Simply because Hibberds js is scetchy at best and the last thing u want to do is have a 'Mitch Wallis' type sitting on your bench...

I'll say it again...if you have the chance to upgrade to premium...DO IT! DO IT NOW!!

[Bluke]

YES SIR!