Dangerfield, Duncan or Gilbee?

Started by Jukes, May 19, 2011, 05:43:34 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Danger, Dunks or Gilbs?

Duncan
1 (12.5%)
Dangerfield
6 (75%)
Gilbee
1 (12.5%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Jukes

I'm getting rid of Gram, and am lookin at Lindsay Gilbee or Mitch Duncan or Paddy Dangerfield. Who should I trade in?

lukedogg17

i wouldnt really be pleased with any of them, got any other options? but if i had to pick one itd be dangerfield coz damn hes awesome

chrisuzz

Dangerfield only got his first ever DT ton (during the season) last round, but ive had him from the start of the year and havent really been disspointed, that ton only means hes on his way up though! ;)

Montag

none. where are you traded in (i assume mids) and how much money do you have
for 350k and under i like the look of liam shiels from hawks
there is also joel corey at around 350k mark
ryan okeefe and luke hodge sit at 328k and theyre good money
daniel rich at 316k is a good buy
sloane at 286 is hot but you have to get in quick

for me i would go in order
depending on money
1- shiels
2- corey
3- sloane
4- hodge
5- rich
6- okeefe

Ziplock

none. Get real premiums or go home :P

Montag

yeah if you can afford them
if not get the best most consistent player with job security
like corey, shies, hodge

chrisuzz

Would have to agree with the two of you though 8)

FLOPITOUT1

If i had to have 1 i suppose it would have to be Dang - er

chrisuzz

Also if u are adament to bring in one Danger is playing his 50th on the weekend so should be pumped ;) but its against Collingwood :'(

eski_liddr

Quote from: Montag on May 19, 2011, 05:53:39 PM
none. where are you traded in (i assume mids) and how much money do you have
for 350k and under i like the look of liam shiels from hawks
there is also joel corey at around 350k mark
ryan okeefe and luke hodge sit at 328k and theyre good money
daniel rich at 316k is a good buy
sloane at 286 is hot but you have to get in quick

for me i would go in order
depending on money
1- shiels
2- corey
3- sloane
4- hodge
5- rich
6- okeefe


Would of thought Hodge be first? his price and consistency at that value wont differ (likely to go up). With the others its a semi gamble, you may get consistent scores but at the end of the day Hodge should come up trumps well ahead of the others.

Also considering the last game of the season is hawks v gold coast. A great final game // long term choice if you ask me

Power16

I wouldnt get any of Lindsay Gilbee or Mitch Duncan or Paddy Dangerfield, go for someone else...more consistent if u can..

Jukes

I have up to 317k to spend on this player.

Maybe Callan Ward?

Ziplock

no. Ward was a premium stepping stone unique (and my unique mofos).

Get real premos or gtfo. I'll just say it again and again.

:-X

antonc

Got danger myself (since the start). Either him or Krak will be my supersub for the forwards or mids.
Not sure though if it is good to get him now. Don't think he will be good enough to be in a finished forward line and def NOT in a finished midfield.


chaosAD