What do we think of Carrazzo?

[theswiz]

if you're thinking of carrots then scotland is a good shout - had him last year and would get him again but gibbs + finals bye doesnt work

i agree and disagree.. scotland is more consistent week by week but i want an x-factor... i can cop a 50 if the next week im getting 150...
and like i said earlier... im going for overall... (:
thanks for your input though... unfortunetely scotland is like 3k out of my budget!

[theswiz]

Hate Shaw, like carrots.

Carrazzo is the winner for me! He is only as inconsistent as any other backman, but Shaw on the other hand brings it to a whole new level...

+1 will agree on that one!!
plus he can 140 it up!

[Holz]

scotland for me, i have had broughton, goddard and grimes kill me all season so i want to get in someone who will certainty average 90+

[Doogie]

I brought in carrots last year about rnd 5 or 6 just before he started his tagging role, pissed me off. But you never know, he could get thrown into that role again.

Got cheap shaw last week even tho i told myself i wouldnt at the start of the season but collingwood are playing well and he can pump out some good scores and is playing well..

But for consistency.. Scotland

[urfresh23]

Carrots is a superstar, had him from the start and has the potential to pump out a massive score

[BillMurray]

If your going for overall I'd say your pretty much no chance. I'm ranked like 1520 something as well and conceded defeat already... :'(

GL anyway though... ;)

[pinochio]

scotland for me, i have had broughton, goddard and grimes kill me all season so i want to get in someone who will certainty average 90+

im thinking along the same way as you man....with shaw/suckling/carrots there is a bit of uncertainty but with scotland its like as close to a sure thing as defenders can offer this year?????

right?

[AlexIsOnFire]

Carlton have a bye in rd 23 so no good if your going to play finals in your league

That's the deal-breaker for me. Was strongly considering him but with gibbs in backline as well it's too big a hole left in my side during finals... :(

Move Gibbs into the mid, then bring Carrats in

[pinochio]

Carrots or Scotland....

the 'ol debate > Age vs. consistency???

[DT Junkie]

Dangerous play I reckon... If your league means anything to you this will just about balls it up cos come prelim youll have gibbs and another blue to offload... By then i doubt youll have many trades left!

[theswiz]

Dangerous play I reckon... If your league means anything to you this will just about balls it up cos come prelim youll have gibbs and another blue to offload... By then i doubt youll have many trades left!

as has been said many times im after overall! i couldnt give a rats toss about league!

[Bluke]

If its overall you are going for then based on his current form, its not a bad choice at all.

[theswiz]

If its overall you are going for then based on his current form, its not a bad choice at all.

thanks for the advice!

[cameron1]

he has been given a tagging role every week this year and is still getting great scores due to his tackle count
ill be bringing him in this week over shaw even though i can get anyone i want. I am also going for overall and couldn't care less about league wins

[MissPiesFF]

As much as I love my heater!(so much so in the cold winter months ;) Carrots for me as Carlton wont have a bye until round 23.