Enright vs. Suckling

[bigsy]

Guys, just need to know what you think!

My backs atm are : Gibbs, Deledio, Goddard, Heppell, Puopolo, Stanley, Lower (Otten, L. Thompson, Guthrie)

Cash remaining: $43 400

Thinking Thompson--->Hibberd
             Otten--->?????

Or is Heath Shaw a better option for his slightly higher price??

[Grazz]

Id go Suckling 1st, Enright will get cheaper if you can wait.

[Holz]

im not very cinfident in either iwould save up abit and go to someone like scotland who is one of the few reasonably consistent backs.

[C-Dogg]

im not very cinfident in either iwould save up abit and go to someone like scotland who is one of the few reasonably consistent backs.

X2

[vmac66]

maybe fisher..?

[Yoshi]

im not very cinfident in either iwould save up abit and go to someone like scotland who is one of the few reasonably consistent backs.

Scottland would be a good choice except for the bye Rd23. Most people would also have Gibbs meaning you are 2 players down.

I'd take Suckling over Enright. You also have Malceski due back later in the season.

[bundyboy]

today...suckling...

2 weeks time...  enright..he will just be too cheap to ignore....

[theswiz]

enright... hes  geelongan!

[McRooster]

Suckling so tempting at a b/e of 22 and at that sort of coin he becomes a keeper who will play v GC in DT GF.....

Thompson and Otten (when he returns) both still have some growth left in them. However Otten IS injured and Lower was subbed off last week and is nearing his ave v b/e???

I'd go Lower to Hibberd/Jacobs and Otten to Suckling.

[bigsy]

Suckling so tempting at a b/e of 22 and at that sort of coin he becomes a keeper who will play v GC in DT GF.....

Thompson and Otten (when he returns) both still have some growth left in them. However Otten IS injured and Lower was subbed off last week and is nearing his ave v b/e???

I'd go Lower to Hibberd/Jacobs and Otten to Suckling.

Cheers mate, that's good advice. I also just think that Enright is a teensy bit overrated

[ossie85]

Enright!!

What's with all the Suckling love? Enright is a proven champion. When in doubt, pick the better player. Not like Geelong aren't playing well. Yes, Enright will get cheaper, but I'd wait.

Heath Shaw could will Collingwood's best and fairest at this rate and is a huge chance for All-Aus, reckon he's stepped up this year.

[thatguy]

black listed heath shaw is very close to coming off that list with his current form! and i hate admitting it!

[bigsy]

black listed heath shaw is very close to coming off that list with his current form! and i hate admitting it!

sorry i don't understand what you mean by that

[korza]

I have Suckling and Enright Khunt help. Go the sucker then Enright later on.


KORZA

[Fenno]

black listed heath shaw is very close to coming off that list with his current form! and i hate admitting it!

Im exactly the same. But if I do the unthinkable and get him he is sure to punish me with his inconsistant crap