J Brown & P Chapman In

Started by Rated_RKO, May 17, 2011, 06:45:45 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

I wanna get Brown and Chapman in, Who to trade out ?

Higgins / Tapscott
1 (8.3%)
Higgins / Matera
2 (16.7%)
Dangerfield / Tapscott
2 (16.7%)
Dangerfield / D Harris
0 (0%)
D Harris / Matera
7 (58.3%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Voting closed: May 19, 2011, 06:45:45 PM

Rated_RKO

Dont know if Higgins is worth keeping considering he is injury prone
Dont know who is worth keeping between Matera and Tapscott

dicey7

dpends on when you want to trade

Rated_RKO

i can do one before this week and another in a week or 2 ... depending on how much J Brown will drop in value.

dicey7

hmmm if your not going for overall id wait on chappy because his price will drop over the coming weeks and id give brown a week just to see how he is travelling.

This also allows your rooks to make little more money

Rated_RKO

haha i was going for overall a few weeks ago, but had a few bad weeks .. went from 412 down to 3000-something in a matter of 3 weeks. so now im just happy to be winning my league, sitting on top, undefeated and a game ahead of everyone else.

Holz

if you are planning  on trading out Higgins due to injury concern and than you trade in brown ( a guy coming of an injury and his injury of last year) and than chappy probably the most famous case of missing a couploe fo weeks due to injury.

i would drop danger, matera and tapscott.

fortynine

Higgins & Matera

Higgins burns you too many times, injury prone as hell and isn't immune to the wrath of Eades drop-hammer.
Matera is exciting to watch and a little jet capable of kicking goals but he's a forward pocket type, often chasing kicks and tackles.

JB is an interesting pick mate, I wouldn't do it personally right now, give him a look and wait for Chappy to drop a bit more, his B/E is 176 this week and he's playing Carlton who are travelling well...I'd rather ROK to be honest

Holz

Quote from: fortynine on May 17, 2011, 07:02:23 PM
Higgins & Matera

Higgins burns you too many times, injury prone as hell and isn't immune to the wrath of Eades drop-hammer.
Matera is exciting to watch and a little jet capable of kicking goals but he's a forward pocket type, often chasing kicks and tackles.

JB is an interesting pick mate, I wouldn't do it personally right now, give him a look and wait for Chappy to drop a bit more, his B/E is 176 this week and he's playing Carlton who are travelling well...I'd rather ROK to be honest

why replace 1 injury prone player with another. Especially when higgins is averaging over 100 and is even scoring more consistently than chapman this year.

Rated_RKO

thanks for the input guys, i think i'll hold off a week or two on that now
especially as i just looked at my backline and realised i should upgrade at least one of my bench rookies ( Lower B.Smith Stanley) to a premium and then take Puopolo off the field as emergency ... maybe i'll space the trades out over the next 5 - 6 weeks or so