who should i upgrade too

[starz]

who should i upgrade too thanks

[Ziplock]

based on current form, shaw hands down. Based on proven consistency, scotland, hands down.

Your call. Depends what you value the most.

honestly, I don't know why I went enright instead of shaw and I could be kicking myself for the rest of the season over it.

[Andrew]

Who wants Scotland's PF bye in the DT finals..?

[jvalles]

based on current form, shaw hands down. Based on proven consistency, scotland, hands down.

Your call. Depends what you value the most.

honestly, I don't know why I went enright instead of shaw and I could be kicking myself for the rest of the season over it.

You went Enright coz he is a proven, consistent backman, did the disciplined thing.  Shaw was more of a risk that seems to have paid off for people.

Personally I love Scotland, but if you've already got Gibbs then you might struggle when Carlton have their next bye in the finals.

[Rated_RKO]

it all depends if you think you are gonna get the win in the first week of finals so you have a bye in the 2nd week, therefore it wouldnt matter if you have carlton players or not.. unless of course you want to finish number 1 in all of dreamteam.
but the unique pick would be scotland

[Grazz]

If its out of those 2 id go Shaw as people have stated above you will be without Scotland in
our Pre-lim final. Im guessing you have Gibbs also so Shaw would be the smart move but there
are others. Not knowing all your backline makes this hard to advise on.

[starz]

sorry backline is
lids gibbs hepel goddard adcock lower jacobs
toy puopolo stanley

[starz]

by the way im going for the school win and i have to be at the top of the statye by round 20

[starz]

any thoughts

[Ziplock]

you want a flat yes or no answer, then shaw.

[FLOPITOUT1]

Shaw or Enright  :-\

[gerco]

it all depends if you think you are gonna get the win in the first week of finals so you have a bye in the 2nd week, therefore it wouldnt matter if you have carlton players or not.. unless of course you want to finish number 1 in all of dreamteam.
but the unique pick would be scotland

Carlton's bye is in Round 23, which is PF week, not Round 22 which is SF week.

[Grazz]

Scotland will probably give you consistent 90-95 with little risk of throwing in a shocker.
Shaw i think will avg around the ton but has the potential to throw in a wobbly score every
now and then but can also give you 120+'s. With your situation ie needing to be number1
by round 20 (Think thats what you meant) then Scotland could be the less riskier of the two
for you. Long story short i dont think you can go to far wrong with either of them. As for me
i will trying to get Shaw in at some stage, only reason for that is the Carlton bye in rnd 23
and i dont want to burn more than 2 trades on guns in the DT finals otherwise id be just as
happy with Scotland in my side. Best of luck.