Fyfe cv's Mundy...worth the extra cash??

bundyboy · May 16, 2011, 11:02:21 PM

need to trade this week to get a mid fielder to avoid donut + one more mid trade to lock away my midfield.

plan was to get swann, but with high BE he will be cheaper next week for me, but still need a mid this week - so trying to decide who. Needs to be a keeper - so quality is important..

Mundy showing great consistency and looks to be super...but Fyfe averaging almost the same including one crappy game - plus MPP benefit,.. gee he is tempting....

already have boyd, pendles, thompson + 1 locked spot for Swann (next week) + ?? whoever I get this week, Last spot swings between chappy, goodes,higgins, gibbs etc..as MPP's - so last spot covered...

big question - who is my lock away number 6 ?? and can't be ablet...- so really narrowing down between fyfe and mundy???

thoughts ?

Nails · May 16, 2011, 11:06:05 PM

13 ppg is a fair difference. Not really "almost the same" for mine.

Mundy like a LOT of players had a poor first game, because it was the first game of the season. Poor for Mundy being 87 lol

Since round 2 now that's he's up and going he's averaging 117.83 and well let's face it, UNDERRATED :D

Jump on the Mundiggity dawg train/boat/plane. (Yes he offers multiple modes of transportation)

p.s. 600 posts :) ;D

LaHug · May 16, 2011, 11:08:15 PM

Mundy without a doubt!

Andrew · May 16, 2011, 11:09:35 PM

Definately Mundy unless Fyfe's dual position is particularly valuable to your side.

Chopps · May 16, 2011, 11:10:09 PM

get mundy

bundyboy · May 16, 2011, 11:18:04 PM

well...seems like the jury is undecided......not....

guess i will give away the $$ saving and get on the boat/train/plane....

Nails · May 16, 2011, 11:21:49 PM

Quote from: bundyboy on May 16, 2011, 11:18:04 PM
well...seems like the jury is undecided......not....

guess i will give away the $$ saving and get on the boat/train/plane....

Sorry Sir, I, Mundiggity Dawg Train Conductor would like to inform you that you can only ride one form of transportation at once and will therefore have to choose which form you will take this week.

No multi-transport is available.

antonc · May 16, 2011, 11:49:22 PM

going mundy (foley) this week and prob ablett (harris) next week (why don't you want to get SOG in?) and prob swann for A Swallow after his second bye.
Midfield by next week will be pendles boyd selwood mundy ablett and aswallow. Pretty handy I think.

bundyboy · May 16, 2011, 11:49:55 PM

ok - if i have to choose....i'm jumping on the Mundy Skate Board !! ;D

bundyboy · May 16, 2011, 11:56:07 PM

reason i must trade this week into mids is because i have swallow, harris, illes and curnow all in midfield.

4 not playing next week, and none of them MPP ...

was never going to be an issue, because I had curnow pencilled as a keeper and was planning on trading swallow/harris this week once their price peaked.
EXCEPT that plan screwed last week with Harris having an early rest last week, curnow injured...and now swallow scores a big 100...so both GC players have more money to make - so curnow from a keeper becomes a forced trade....

long winded answer - that's why i can't take GAJ because still leaves me with 4 non players this week ...otherwise i would have !!

Andrew · May 17, 2011, 12:04:11 AM

Quote from: bundyboy on May 16, 2011, 11:56:07 PM
reason i must trade this week into mids is because i have swallow, harris, illes and curnow all in midfield.

4 not playing next week, and none of them MPP ...

was never going to be an issue, because I had curnow pencilled as a keeper and was planning on trading swallow/harris this week once their price peaked.
EXCEPT that plan screwed last week with Harris having an early rest last week, curnow injured...and now swallow scores a big 100...so both GC players have more money to make - so curnow from a keeper becomes a forced trade....

long winded answer - that's why i can't take GAJ because still leaves me with 4 non players this week ...otherwise i would have !!

Mate I've got the same deliemma, throw in Bewick for good measure (looks dodgy). Like you, Curnow is just about a forced trade this week. I. Smith looks like a good pick and it just about a midfield upgrade for me anyway as I swap him with Goodes in my forward line, so not the worst. But I'm somewhat regretting the Libba -> Iles trade as I wouldn't be in this situation if I didn't do it (pluis would've got the 100/save a trade). Duigan -> Enright is looking the same. Maybe I have traded a little too hard but I'll be buying Assistant Coach if I play this seriously again next year - it's too helpful!

antonc · May 17, 2011, 12:10:45 AM

Good luck with mundy bundy Lol
Hope he does well for us!!!!

Possumo · May 17, 2011, 01:16:40 AM

Quote from: bundyboy on May 16, 2011, 11:02:21 PM
need to trade this week to get a mid fielder to avoid donut + one more mid trade to lock away my midfield.

plan was to get swann, but with high BE he will be cheaper next week for me, but still need a mid this week - so trying to decide who. Needs to be a keeper - so quality is important..

Mundy showing great consistency and looks to be super...but Fyfe averaging almost the same including one crappy game - plus MPP benefit,.. gee he is tempting....

already have boyd, pendles, thompson + 1 locked spot for Swann (next week) + ?? whoever I get this week, Last spot swings between chappy, goodes,higgins, gibbs etc..as MPP's - so last spot covered...

big question - who is my lock away number 6 ?? and can't be ablet...- so really narrowing down between fyfe and mundy???

thoughts ?

What is Swan's B/E exactly? I thought this week was the week to get him, and like you I'm doing it to cover a doughnut, with Curnow, Iles, Swallow and Harris in my team still too. I'm probably in a different position though in that I reckon I need Swan this week to be competitive against my opponent... keen on Mundy as a 6th Mid too...