Is this the best I can do?

Started by jvalles, May 16, 2011, 06:05:50 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

jvalles

Making four trades over the next 2 weeks, anything I can do better?

Backs: Delidio, Gibbs, Goddard, Enright, Heppell, Puopolo, Lower (Stanley, Toy, B.Smith)
Mids: Swan, J.Selwood, A.Swallow, Boyd, Atley, Liberatore (Harris, Prestia, Jacobs)
Ruck: Cox, Petrie (Z.Smith, Bailey)
Forw: Goodes, Chapman, S.Johnson, N.Riewoldt, Fyfe, Knights, Frankilin (Darling, Tapscott, C.Richardson)

Not interested in doing anything with my backs as noone is standing out, and they all have their own risks.  Petrie will become Sandi later on.

Week 1
Downgrade B.Smith -> Hibberd
Upgrade Atley -> Mundy

Week 2
Downgrade Tapscott ->Lynch/Mzungu (coz he will get a game soon and is cheaper than Lynch)
Upgrade Heppell/Liberatore -> Rischetelli/Montagna/Mitchell (feel that Heppell has reached his max & looks to be losing out to Hibberd a bit, also coz of the Bombers bye this week and in the finals)

Other option is to Downgrade both B.Smith -> Hibberd and Tapscott -> I.Smith

Please discuss.  :D

Problems

Pretty sure Lynch is on the bubble this week. If you're worried about Hibberd affecting Heppell then how do you think Charlie Dixon will affect Lynch's scores when he returns?

Mushi

Quote from: Problems on May 16, 2011, 06:21:02 PM
Pretty sure Lynch is on the bubble this week. If you're worried about Hibberd affecting Heppell then how do you think Charlie Dixon will affect Lynch's scores when he returns?

You mean next week

Problems

Quote from: Mushi on May 16, 2011, 06:51:24 PM
Quote from: Problems on May 16, 2011, 06:21:02 PM
Pretty sure Lynch is on the bubble this week. If you're worried about Hibberd affecting Heppell then how do you think Charlie Dixon will affect Lynch's scores when he returns?

You mean next week
Yeah my bad  :-[ bye round confusing me  :-X

jvalles

Quote from: Problems on May 16, 2011, 06:21:02 PM
Pretty sure Lynch is on the bubble this week. If you're worried about Hibberd affecting Heppell then how do you think Charlie Dixon will affect Lynch's scores when he returns?

Think you might be right about Lynch and the extra 20-30k for a rookies may not be worth it.  Mzungu will be the man is I don't do the double downgrade this week.

Ziplock

if he can keep up averaging even 80, then it is. If he keeps up averaging 90, then it certainly is.

Andrew

Smith -> Suckling looks like a no brainer for you. If you need a downgrade to do it, maybe A. Swallow -> I. Smith..?

jvalles

Quote from: Andrew on May 17, 2011, 05:35:09 PM
Smith -> Suckling looks like a no brainer for you. If you need a downgrade to do it, maybe A. Swallow -> I. Smith..?

I'm a bit wary of Sucklings inflated scores, and Swallow was chosen as a keeper so reluctant to move him on as I have to upgrade him again at some point...but I prob will move him before the Roos bye...hmmm, you've given me some thought there, thanks.