which MPP rookie ??

[bundyboy]

need to pick up one of these as downgrade for next week so i can pick up Swanny and avoid a midfield donut...

so - which one??

big wraps on Jacobs, but really didn't impress me as i watched the game...

Hibberd - better this week than last, and big wraps again pre-season, but will he have the job security in Ess team ?

views ??  and votes please..

[MarkPlow]

wait to see who's named

[yorgis]

benny should have better js . played first game against sydney, at scg, across 1/2 back and was/inundated with inside 50's after 1/2 time. turned the ball over a couple of times but managed to pick up 15 pos and 5 marks 

[blah128]

Would love to see another game from Jacobs before picking...obvious 1st game nerves so will improve and looks like better JS. Hibberd probably has some improvement left in him too so hopefully he can impress and hold his spot. Hibberd if it needs to happen this week

[m_zulian]

Hibberd if it needs to happen this week

Totally agree. If you need to trade this week, trade in Hibberd.
I am looking at trading Lower out Hibberd in

[tappy21]

i reckon jacobs has better job security as port are going down the youth track. hibberd has performed well in both games he has played but i think will be a fringe 22 player for the rest of the year as the bombers are now pushing for top 4 spot