We might be in a little bit of a pickle, Dick.

Started by wce06, May 12, 2011, 07:53:34 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

wce06

Backline: Goddard, Deledio, Grimes, Broughton, Heppell, Stanley, Lower (Gibbs, Duigan, Otten)
Mids: Swan, Boyd, Bartel, Anthony, D. Swallow, Libba (Bewick, Hibberd, Harris)

So here's the dilemma. 23 trades, 13k in bank. Was originally gonna downgrade Otten to Puopolo/Jacobs and trade Grimes to Enright/Rawlings/H.Shaw etc. But now that Anthony is out (good riddance, been underwhelming to say the least) I'm thinking of getting rid of him instead of Grimes this round for either J.Selwood/Mundy/Mitchell.

Option 1
Otten -> Puopolo/B.Jacobs (choose one)
Grimes -> Enright/Rawlings/H.Shaw/Other
Put Bewick on field for Anthony
Deal with Anthony next week

Option 2
Otten -> Puopolo/B.Jacobs (choose one)
Anthony -> Mundy/Mitchell/J.Selwood
Puopolo/Jacobs on field for Grimes

EDIT - Option 3
Anthony -> I.Smith/Jacobs (I.Smith/Jacobs or Bewick on field)
Grimes -> Enright/Rawlings/H.Shaw/Other

Trades obviously pending Friday Teams

wce06

Hey guys, I hate to ask for replies but I kinda need them :-\

thanme

That's a tough one. I'd probably go with option 2 and Puopolo if it was me. That being said, I'm all about getting my mid field sorted out at the moment!

Nails

I didn't fully read all your option cause it was tl;dr

but I'd go

Grimes > Jacobs
Anthony > Premium of your choice.

Jacobs is a gun and could be Heppell 2.0 for all we know. You'll want to get him in your team eventually so don't waste your time thinking otherwise. Grimes > Jacobs get it done now!

yorgis


LF


FLOPITOUT1

Option 3  Anthony-Smith   Grimes-Enright.

FLOPITOUT1

Quote from: FLOPITOUT1 on May 13, 2011, 03:48:51 PM
Option 3  Anthony-Smith   Grimes-Enright.
Your gonna have to upgrade in the mids tho at some stage

wce06

Thanks guys I appreciate it. If I do option 3 I'll have 200k for a mid upgrade next week. Leaning that way atm.