REDO: Which Saint?

[TMurphBROWNLOW]

Montagna
Price: $409,800
Overall Average: 98.33
Last 3 Round Average: 101.67
Breakeven: 140

VS

Dal Santo
Price: 393,100
Overall Average: 102.67
Last 3 Round Average: 96.33
Breakeven: 83


AND

Gram
Price: 330,100
Overall Average: 85.5
Last 3 Round Average: 69.67
Breakeven: 132

VS

Fisher
Price: $343,000
Overall Average: 85.5
Last 3 Round Average: 90.3
Breakeven: 100

THANK YOU IN ADVANCE :)

[LaHug]

Why get St. Kilda players...? I'd wait another week to see whether or not last night was just flukey.

[Ziplock]

these are all pretty proven guns, if st kilda lifts, which they will, all these players will lift.

[TMurphBROWNLOW]

Why get St. Kilda players...? I'd wait another week to see whether or not last night was just flukey.

with grimes' injury your safest bet is someone who has proven himself over the years. i think i might put in fisher this week, simply because he looks like he's on the rise.

+ both montagna and dal santo are averaging 98+, i think that's satisfying for your 6th midfielder come season's end.

[LaHug]

Why get St. Kilda players...? I'd wait another week to see whether or not last night was just flukey.

with grimes' injury your safest bet is someone who has proven himself over the years. i think i might put in fisher this week, simply because he looks like he's on the rise.

+ both montagna and dal santo are averaging 98+, i think that's satisfying for your 6th midfielder come season's end.

I agree that these guys are proven. But I'd want all of my midfielders averaging over 100. Preferably 105+.

[TMurphBROWNLOW]

Why get St. Kilda players...? I'd wait another week to see whether or not last night was just flukey.

with grimes' injury your safest bet is someone who has proven himself over the years. i think i might put in fisher this week, simply because he looks like he's on the rise.

+ both montagna and dal santo are averaging 98+, i think that's satisfying for your 6th midfielder come season's end.

I agree that these guys are proven. But I'd want all of my midfielders averaging over 100. Preferably 105+.

fair enough, but i can't see a midfield with Swan, Pendlebury, Selwood, Bartel happening for me. having two sets of premium midfielders from the same team doesn't appeal to me at all. i only plan to have 3 of those, 2 of which i already have.

[LaHug]

Cbf quoting all that...
I've got Pendles, Selwood, Boyd as premiums atm. I intend on having one fwd/mid MPP as my 6th spot (so might only be averaging about 100, but gives me cover) and then Swan and whoever I feel like later. I guess it's a lot harder this year. I'm hoping that a few DPPs will have high averages (already have Chapman, Pavlich, Harvey).

[Andrew]

Wait a week on Gram/Fisher. I'd lean towards Gram because of his dual position but Fisher scored the 100 last night.

[LaHug]

Wait a week on Gram/Fisher. I'd lean towards Gram because of his dual position but Fisher scored the 100 last night.

I'd consider Fisher the better player, but Gram is a DT slut. I'd go Gram out of them.

[TMurphBROWNLOW]

Wait a week on Gram/Fisher. I'd lean towards Gram because of his dual position but Fisher scored the 100 last night.

I'd consider Fisher the better player, but Gram is a DT slut. I'd go Gram out of them.

grams last 3 games have been well below his best... 84, 54, 71 is putting me off really bad!