Main Menu

Worst Commentator!!

Started by Carnthedockers, May 31, 2009, 06:26:47 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

dreamteamking

Robert Walls is the best by far!

The worst was Stephen Silvagni... thankfully he doesn't do it anymore...

I HATE Ray Warren in the NRL...

tom_scully

Andrew Maher, can't stand his drawl and the way he pronounces words.

jackpayet

Dunno but Dennis Cometti is the best by far!

yeahsup

No way is Robert Walls the best.

Crows90

Glenn Jackovich by a mile. Not only is his voice annoying but his bias towards the Eagles is just ridiculous.

CaptDH

Robert Walls is a terrible commentator and has a worse football brain.

His theories are usually borrowed or stupid.  Carlton had an awesome team the year he coached them to a premiership. They probably would've played better if he wasn't there.

Worst commentator ever (Cast your mind back a few years) = Graham Cornes.  Absolutely excruciating 

nas

AAaaRRrrGGggHHhh

Listened to this bird Re last week Geelong v Melbourne

Kelli Underwood  > Listening to her commentating a footy match reminds me of my nagging wife

valkorum

Naste

I had to turn it over to the game as it was just too unbearable with it.  She was "trying" way too hard.

eaglejay

As others have mentioned i dislike listening to robert walls the most.

2Fat2Old

The Fat Man agrees, even Mrs Fat said it doesn't sound right having a females voice talking football lingo like a male. It's a bit like walking into one of the drinking holes down at Alberton, listening to one of the "BOOZE HAGS" swearing, cursing in the drunken manner that makes anyone turn away and go somewhere else.
Maybe if it was more of a specialty roll like the boundry riders do, it wouldn't sound so out of place.

MMM   "SPECIALTY ROLL"   YUMM
          (double cut please)

bensomerford

if it counts, Drew Banfield was the worst in history. He was a boundary rider for AFL games at subi. but he really struggled to get sentences out and umm and arghhed alot. was tripe, really god awful.

so he got a run for one season before the network he worked for decided he really couldnt do his job. it was never explained where and why he went, but I thnk most of us worked it out.

2Fat2Old

What an intersting day it would be listening to a Warrick Capper/Rex Hunt/Jason Dunstall & Caroline Wilson combination calling the game.
Major arguements there i'd reckon.

At least we'd get a laugh.

jackpayet

bensomerford I'm pretty sure Drew Banfield was playing in the south west football league last year as a paid player for souths

bensomerford

u missed the point, jackpayet  :P

jackpayet

Well I'm telling you where he went arent I?