Trade or sit tight???

[pinochio]

My mid field rookies have got some fattening to do yet...bewick/prestia/harris/curnow and i already have hibberd so dont know who i can downgrade duigan too???

around 15k off duigan/otten for enright/jacobs....only real trade i can do is curnow down to wallis and duigan/otten up to enright??

Is it best for me to sit tight and prob downgrade tapscott for harper next round and upgrade otten/duigan to enright since mid rookies have a bit of growing to do....chappy can be brought in for petrie in couple of rounds...

or should trade duigan for jacobs for cash since i have only 18k???


Appreciate the help!

[Fenno]

wouldn't be surprised to see jacobs gets a gig for port this weekend so if you wanted to take a risk and get him before he is on the bubble he could be an option for a downgrade

[pinochio]

considering first post would
Roo/duigan FOR chappy/jacobs be better then
curnow/duigan FOR enright/wallis (can also be Chappy/Jacobs)


???

[Ziplock]

Only if you think roo will consider his ball sucking ways (no offence to any non-st kilda who suck balls).

You are cutting curnow a bit premature. If you want my honest opinion, enright won't do well this week, if you look at his scores, his worst one from memory was against port adelaide (the worst team), so, against the lions I sincerly doubt he will have a significant price rise.

That being said, I'm trading him in this week :P

[pinochio]

is it better for me just to do like a downgrade or two cause the numbers arnt really adding up...2k short of enright without trading curnow...


duigan > jacobs AND/OR Otten > jacobs AND/OR prestia/bewick/harris > wallis


so many choices!!!
argggggggggggg

[Ziplock]

downgrade duigan.

[pinochio]

so zippy u reckon harris/bewick/prestia have more fattening to do...which i think ur right...

duigan > puopolo/pederson/jacobs what bout also otten to one of the aforementioned???

[Holz]

can you go otten/duigan to jacob and shaw/carrots

[Windigo]

Nick Roo will come good, if good is to strong a word. He will improve, his a champ and I will wait.  8)

[Ziplock]

Holz has the right idea again.

Certainly downgrade duigan over anyone else atm, has a bye next week, which means 4 weeks before that shocking score is out and he can have any substantial cash rise.

and put in jacobs over puoplo/ pederson. JS for most of the reason, atm port could improve their game playing a crippled anaconda.

[Windigo]

Duigan is high priority to kick out, and if his named...Don't beat around the bush. Get Benny.  ;)

[Ziplock]

Benjac is the way to go if named.

[pinochio]

@ Windigo ye was just looking at rooeys past early year scores of previous and they are quite bad (no doubt ppl then were think the same as us now...80-90 first 4 weeks in 2007...NO DOUBT ppl were thinking the wrost as we are now...

So Rooey is staying put :)......


@ holzman...shaw has a bye now and carrots next round....dont really want them in now i think :S...shaws to much 4k more then enright even but carrots can be afforded but a bye is putting me off tbh


duigan AND otten (if not named) > puopolo/pederson/jacobs


thoughts?

[Memphistopheles]

Why not upgarade Duigan and downgrade a mid.

Bewick to Wallis and Duigan to a premium would be good.

Otherwise Puopolo looks like to debut this week - he's a better bet than most.

[Andrew]

I'm getting Suckling for Duigan and surprised others aren't..?