Suckling or adcock?

Started by Stocutz, April 27, 2011, 01:16:44 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which one?

adcock
suckling
someone else?

Stocutz

Who to upgrade to? I'm going to downgrade ward just not pulling the scores out and sone1like polec will score somewhere round the mark for 120k save.

If I pick adcock I gotta go this week obviously can wait a week with suckling.

Just feel adcock is a gun and will really be used a lot by the lions youngsters.

Thoughts?

Backs: Gibbs deledio grimes Goddard Murphy heppell       Otten stanly lower duigan

Also out of the last 4 who should I use for the trade? I was leaning towards otten

cledus32

I do like adcock, but be careful with Drummond and Mcguire looking to both return this week, i can see them, especially Drummond eating into adcocks DT & SC points.

Centimeter Perfect

 Why not get both. The Suck-Cock combination may work wonders.

Stocutz

Quote from: cledus32 on April 27, 2011, 01:33:35 PM
I do like adcock, but be careful with Drummond and Mcguire looking to both return this week, i can see them, especially Drummond eating into adcocks DT & SC points.

Mmmm it's a tough one. Might free adcock into the midfield more tho I would have thought. By all reports suckling has been playing very well tho and played great yesterday and js should be very good now. Plus the money saved on suckling prob amts to 10-15ppg.
Aaahhhh still unsure

shents

In the same boat. I'm going to go Otten to suckling next week, I think Adcock has too much risk. Kind of missed the boat as well. With his his injury history, and drummond coming back in this week, Adcock could find he won't get much of the ball anymore.

Stocutz

Quote from: shents on April 27, 2011, 01:47:10 PM
In the same boat. I'm going to go Otten to suckling next week, I think Adcock has too much risk. Kind of missed the boat as well. With his his injury history, and drummond coming back in this week, Adcock could find he won't get much of the ball anymore.

Y would the inclusion of Drummond who is not only coming back from injury but the year before doing a knee going to have great effect on adcock? I can't see how. Hes the designated kicker but will he dominate early? No way. Does he break line run and carry it like adcock? No. They r different players and Drummond will take some time to regain past form/ influence on games

JR23

im in a similar boat... im going to "downgrade" Lake who, i KNOW i got too early and thought he would make an immediate impact. and i dont care if its a "wasted" trade. if im saving cash from his MASSIVE price drop and getting a back average over 100 to lake's 59average, its not a wasted trade to me

anyway my backs are

deledio, gibbs, goddard, heppell, lower, otten, lake   and  subs: coad, toy, hibberd

if you were to pick ANYONE else to be on your team if those were your backs, money is NO object, who would you pick? who is MUST HAVE?

Ziplock

it's a wasted trade. If you think he'll return to his premium status, then it's wasted, pure and simple. You only trade out premiums if they are chronically underperforming, and you don't think they can return to their prior scoring ability.

if lake gets back to last year's average, then 'losing cash' doesn't mean showerall.

Master Q


LaHug

Quote from: Master Q on April 27, 2011, 04:57:58 PM
Adcock.
I couldn't help but read that in Vader's voice. Q, your new picture is finally getting to me!

BillMurray


I have ward and while I'm not over the moon with Ward's second term fade-outs I'll be hanging onto him for a while longer. With some more tackles his 70 odd efforts can easily jump to 85-90 mark like his first few scores. Plus I think Polec is too pricey a downgrade option at around 140k; I'll be waiting for the likes of 97k rookies as downgrades for Ward.
- If your dead set on trading however, I think Suckling is amazing value at just under 300k and with the bye you get another weeks price rise out of your cash cows. Looks to be a great fit as 6th defender.

Stocutz

Quote from: BillMurray on April 27, 2011, 05:23:09 PM

I have ward and while I'm not over the moon with Ward's second term fade-outs I'll be hanging onto him for a while longer. With some more tackles his 70 odd efforts can easily jump to 85-90 mark like his first few scores. Plus I think Polec is too pricey a downgrade option at around 140k; I'll be waiting for the likes of 97k rookies as downgrades for Ward.
- If your dead set on trading however, I think Suckling is amazing value at just under 300k and with the bye you get another weeks price rise out of your cash cows. Looks to be a great fit as 6th defender.

What u say has a lot o merit. However I feel polec is going to score maybe 10-15 less than ward on ave and or a saving of 120k it's juicy. Plus it will allow me to upgrade a a def given that my other mid/fwd/def rookies haven't peaked yet.
Also either I make te trade this week or scrap it as polecs 1st rise will have him outta reach.