Carrazo, possible super trade in?

[Holz]

I have been thinking of going broughton to carrazzo all week and not one person has agreed it is a good trade. He was shocking against collingwood but his other 3 games he averaged 110 from them. Last year i think he averaged around 95 in his first 10 games and than went tagging and dropped his average. IF he stays away from his tagging and i know thats a big iff than he seems to score around 100 most weeks.  I would neve pick him up for league but for overall his roller-coaster scores don't matter.

the only other option i can think of is broughton to toy, however that leaves me with 220k and im not sure what to do with that. Ward to montagna seems like a waste as montagna will come down in price and ward will go up, if i planned to do this than i would need to wait the week so i can afford to go krak to selwood in round 7.

[Ziplock]

I'm against this Holz, as I think I said before. As you said, carrots will smash out the hundreds whenever he doesn't tag. But, fact is, he's a pretty damn good tagger (despite the fact that he failed tagging shaw in collingwood), so, yeah, if he isn't used as a tagger he'll drill it. But, in all honesty, why wouldn't Carlton use him as a tagger if he's so valuable in that position?

I mean go for it bro, but I think it'll bite you.

I would do the broughton to toy. Post your team up but and we can all go over it and see if your 220k can be used elsewhere?

[Holz]

in caps are my untouchables they wont be traded out of my team bar injury, i havent put rookies as caps but i wont to keep most of them as i don't think they are ready yet.

GODDARD,GIBBS, ADCOCK, GRIMES, broughton, HEPPEL, otten (lower, duigan, stanley)
SWAN, BOYD, anthony, BARTEL, ward, curnow (harris, krak, bewick)
SANDILANS, COX (SMITH, TIPPET)
FRANKLIN, STEVIE J, HIGGINS, VOLDT, KNIGHTS, petrie, tapscott (darling, richardson, matera)

alot of people are saying krak to pav/dids but im not a huge fan of that becasue krak is in my mids, so i dont really want ward sitting on my bench.  If i did the ward to montagna this week than i fall short i think of getting in selwood round 7.

[Ziplock]

maybe do the broughts to toy, then consider offloading petrie next week?

[Holz]

maybe do the broughts to toy, then consider offloading petrie next week?

im highly biased to roos players but i think he should start putting up some respectable scores.

[Ziplock]

I was going to bring that up, I just don't think that after this week (unless he posts a huge ass score), he'll be due for much of a price rise. His breakeven is what, 41?

I would strongly look at him personally. Don't know who for, you could pick up close to anyone though :P

[Holz]

I was going to bring that up, I just don't think that after this week (unless he posts a huge ass score), he'll be due for much of a price rise. His breakeven is what, 41?

I would strongly look at him personally. Don't know who for, you could pick up close to anyone though :P

i could bring in pav, dids or syliva for him and would make my forward look alot stronger, but personally if i was to do that than i would think of going tapscott to dids instead.

you are probably right on carrots but 330k for the 5th  highest averaging back is tempting, pity hodge wasnt a backman than i would just pick him up.

[deekay]

pity hodge wasnt a backman than i would just pick him up.

broughton -> hodge. wow wouldnt that be nice.

[Ziplock]

yeah, that is pretty annoying. I'd prefer to keep tapscott over petrie, isn't he avging a bit more atm, and has way more to rise :P

[Holz]

yeah, that is pretty annoying. I'd prefer to keep tapscott over petrie, isn't he avging a bit more atm, and has way more to rise :P

thats assuming petrie keeps getting 60s, taps has only been putting up 60s the last 2 weeks, petrie is capable of some good scores, was never going to score well against collingwood and had a shocker against freo. would be suprised to see 80+ this week against richmond.

[beermee]

i think you'd be better off trading carrazzo out, broughton in - given their current prices....

[Holz]

i think you'd be better off trading carrazzo out, broughton in - given their current prices....

so trade a 93 average player for a 60?

[Windigo]

Carrazo, will get net you 50's. And the occasional 110+

But, at least with Broughton he will be consistent.

Consistently annoying.  :P

If Broughton's smashed it this week. I will contemplate a trade in....

[beermee]

we dont know how suban being out will effect broughton yet - he could be worth holding onto (or buying if you dont have him), yet....

carrots is a pretty frustrayting players to have in your side - he might win you a game everyn now n then, but most week will be a disastor...

[Holz]

i went broughton to toy and krak to dids, maybee should have got in carrots.