The Goddard, Grimes, Higgins, Toy Gamble...

Started by Smeghead, April 20, 2011, 07:21:59 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Smeghead

Thinking about trading either Goddard (BE 193) or Grimes to Toy or Adcock in order to upgrade Gamble to Higgins or Didak.

So, who to lose?
Goddard/Gamble or Grimes/Gamble

and then who to pick up?
Toy/Higgins
Toy/Didak
Adcock/Higgins
Adcock/Didak

The Toy vs Adcock decision will leave me with cash in bank (toy) or not (adcock) for upgrades in rounds 5 thru 9. I am also concerned about over exposure to GCFC players also as there are only so many upgrades one can do.

Thoughts?

Current team with $66,300 in the bank is:

Bryce Gibbs, Jack Grimes, Brett Deledio, Brendon Goddard, Heath Shaw, Nick Duigan, Andy Otten
Brodie Smith, Nick Lower, Danny Stanley

Colin Sylvia, Dane Swan, Matthew Boyd, Joel Selwood, Tom Liberatore, Ed Curnow
Dyson Heppell, David Swallow, Daniel Harris

Aaron Sandilands, Darren Jolly
Joel Tippett, Zachary Smith

Lance Franklin, Nick Riewoldt, Chris Knights, Chris Yarran, Mitch Duncan, Drew Petrie, Cameron Richardson
Ryan Gamble, Andrew Krakouer, Dion Prestia

Smeghead

Of course if it's Grimes, I have to go to Toy...
And if it's Goddard -> Adcock it has to be Higgins... (Which is what I am leaning toward)

DTDreamer

Why would anyone trade Goddard or Grimes, even if their break even is big..

Smeghead

Goddard underperforming so to allow pick up of well performing Higgins (BE 58) or a "underpriced" Didak.

Also plenty of upside to Toy and Goddard could be repicked around R10 as an upgrade target once he has dropped further in price (which he will in next few weeks) if and when he turns around his form.

Not saying that's what will happen, but that's the reasoning as to why...