KRAKOUER & BROUGHTON

Started by love4thegame, April 19, 2011, 06:39:44 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

whats the best move to do ??

Broughton OUT Adcock IN, Krakouer OUT Foley IN
3 (11.1%)
Krakouer OUT Hibberd IN Broughton OUT Gram IN (I think hibberd will debut)
4 (14.8%)
Broughton OUT Adcock IN. Leave Krakouer. 69K left.
9 (33.3%)
Krakouer OUT Hibberd IN 130K left.
2 (7.4%)
NO TRADES.
9 (33.3%)

Total Members Voted: 2

Voting closed: April 22, 2011, 06:39:44 PM

love4thegame

Leave a comment for any alternative ideas please fellas.

Windigo

Wait and see if Hibbo is named first!

love4thegame

Quote from: Windigo on April 19, 2011, 06:41:06 PM
Wait and see if Hibbo is named first!
ill be definitely waiting for the teams to be named.

Windigo

Of course.

Well, Hird at the start of the season stated that "Hibberd would get games in the coming weeks." That's an in-direct quote by the way.

So there has to be at least 2 changes.

Hille & Prismall come into the side. Hibbo could be a sub or he could be left out completely.

ronl

If Hibberd has only had the one game back at Bendigo, I'd seriously doubt he'd be ready yet. 

Just Clancy

I face the same dilemma. Still don't really know what i'm going to do but i'm REALLY tempted to get Gram in...

love4thegame

Yeah makes two of us I've had enough of broughton!

Nails

Broughton Out. Hibberd/Toy in.

Wait and hold one week on Krakouer, if he smashes out 70+ keep him obviously (I'm probably trading him too)

I'm doing this to see how Rockliff/Redden perform along with a few other players that are performing largely above what they did last year, to see whether it's just a 3/4 round effort or sustained improvement.

Therefore I'm going Broughton > Toy/Hibberd, waiting next week for Krakouer and probably Krakouer > Rockliff (or someone else who shows something pretty decent)

love4thegame

Quote from: Nails on April 19, 2011, 09:44:41 PM
Broughton Out. Hibberd/Toy in.

Wait and hold one week on Krakouer, if he smashes out 70+ keep him obviously (I'm probably trading him too)

I'm doing this to see how Rockliff/Redden perform along with a few other players that are performing largely above what they did last year, to see whether it's just a 3/4 round effort or sustained improvement.

Therefore I'm going Broughton > Toy/Hibberd, waiting next week for Krakouer and probably Krakouer > Rockliff (or someone else who shows something pretty decent)
Pretty good idea for you but I've already got toy and if hibberd isnt listed it's no good for me!

bundyboy

give krak another week....his price will hold or go up-and positive points potential....concentrate on others this week ...

gram / adcock for broughton...  that is the question..

love4thegame

Quote from: bundyboy on April 19, 2011, 09:53:19 PM
give krak another week....his price will hold or go up-and positive points potential....concentrate on others this week ...

gram / adcock for broughton...  that is the question..
Well if I don't trade krak I can't get gram so adcock looks the go at the moment cheers.

pardz

What about Broughton to adcock, krak to jack riewoldt ?

Holz

Quote from: pardz on April 20, 2011, 12:19:39 AM
What about Broughton to adcock, krak to jack riewoldt ?

wouldnt pick up jack in DT, he needs to score 5 goals to even come close to a 100

love4thegame

Quote from: Holzman on April 20, 2011, 12:23:42 AM
Quote from: pardz on April 20, 2011, 12:19:39 AM
What about Broughton to adcock, krak to jack riewoldt ?

wouldnt pick up jack in DT, he needs to score 5 goals to even come close to a 100
Agreed if Richmond was a decent team jack would be great in dt but no. And also krak is a midfielder for me

love4thegame

Looks like broughton out adcock in is the go.