is subans injury turned out to be one of the greatest things of the week

[Montag]

broughtons dt score have been considerably lower this year due to a change in role. now suban is injured will he get his old role back and his scores will skyrocket or will his old role be filled by nick lower

[elephants]

Same goes for duffield. Suban may leave a hole for lower to return too.

[Holz]

i really want to do the broughton to toy trade this week as my bench is outscoring broughton, but suban out and ibbo coming back im not sure if broughton will come back with an 80+ average.

[valkorum]

Or will Ibbo come in and take over from Suban leaving Broughton and Duff to play their current roles.  Who knows?  Harves knows.

I am personally giving Broughts another week or 2 to see what this does for his role.

[Holz]

Or will Ibbo come in and take over from Suban leaving Broughton and Duff to play their current roles.  Who knows?  Harves knows.

I am personally giving Broughts another week or 2 to see what this does for his role.

i was thinking of trading out broughton but as you appear to be the freo guru, i will stay with you. If you were right about fyfe hopefully your correct about this. broughton to toy and krak to pav sure looks tempting though.

[valkorum]

If I was going to trade Broughts I would also be trading to Toy so I actually agree with that trade.  Krak to Pav also makes good sense as a trade. 

I was looking at Broughts to Toy, Krak to Chappy

I keep asking myself am I holding on too long to a Freo player - am I thinking with my head or my heart.  I still think I am gonna give it till Freo have the break - which is only 1 more game.

THIS WAS MY 4000th POST

[Bluke]

I dont think Suban or Ibbo will have any effect on Broughtons output.

I think its a role change in response to the way the game is being played this season.

See here

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,32498.0.html

[valkorum]

Thats actually a good read Bluke and a very interesting theory.  I may have to think about that some more. 

[thornz23]

im done with broughton hey.. gave him this week to c if he could improve because adcock couldnt go up in price. now that he failed agaaaiin ill be going broughton to adcock. theres a chance he will change his role but if he does i guess i could think about upgrading to him later.. but atm he is costing me 30-40 points a week

[Bluke]

Like one of the posters said.. Long to Sandi to clear the zone.

The chip kick to the pocket from Duffield to Broughton and then back again is probably a bit of a coach killer now. Just look at all the clubs coughing it up in situations like that on the weekend. Hawthorn did it a number of times and if they were playing a better opponent they really would have suffered.

[Holz]

hmm even with suban out im still second guessing keeping in broughton im thinking of switching him in for carrots now., as krak should come good at some stage and suban out probably means lower is back in, so i can afford to do the 1 trade next week than drop duigan for a double trade now that lower looks safer.

[elephants]

Duffield -----> adcock + 15k
Thoughts?

[TMurphBROWNLOW]

someone tell Mark Harvey to read some of these posts!!

[Plastic Boy]

If I was going to trade Broughts I would also be trading to Toy so I actually agree with that trade.  Krak to Pav also makes good sense as a trade. 

I was looking at Broughts to Toy, Krak to Chappy

I keep asking myself am I holding on too long to a Freo player - am I thinking with my head or my heart.  I still think I am gonna give it till Freo have the break - which is only 1 more game.

THIS WAS MY 4000th POST

Dont get too emotional and hold on to dud players, Broughton didnt work out this year, I'm sure you would have traded him had he not been from Freo, I would have, its totally unacceptable for a player worth 380k to score 55 each week, he'll be worth 260k after the bye, and you'll be stuck with him, trying to raise cash to upgrade,

Cull him now, before its too late.

[browny_wce]

"has broughtons injury turned out to be the greatest thing of the week"