Trade coad or not

Started by TheHanger, April 18, 2011, 09:45:47 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Should i actually trade coad?

Trade to Toy
Trade Up to Premium
Trade Up to improving rookie (eg. Duigan)
Trade Sideways

Slap

if this is true, which is what i'd be focusing on if I were you, I'd reccomend Toy.  There was hype on him last season, and he has scored a 70 something and a 50 (which was in one half or qtr of footy).

nostradamus

Quote from: Slap on April 19, 2011, 02:01:17 PM
if this is true, which is what i'd be focusing on if I were you, I'd reccomend Toy.  There was hype on him last season, and he has scored a 70 something and a 50 (which was in one half or qtr of footy).

Haven't seen it in a news article yet, but am hoping someone here knows of one.....but have seen it written in a couple of chat posts so far......just hoping its not true


LF


browny_wce

sweet, waste of a trade there

nostradamus

SH!T........thats disappointing, looked like he was gunna do really well too

Thx for the link hirdy and luvfooty

Oh well, who to get in now........toy seems the most likely......just wish this had happened a bit later, we might have had the choice of jacobs and hibberd with the advantage of dpp

Mish

ouch!!! thats gotta suck!! thats why you dont trade a player in before they have a BE!

nostradamus

Quote from: Mish on April 19, 2011, 02:19:39 PM
ouch!!! thats gotta suck!! thats why you dont trade a player in before they have a BE!

l had him from the get go......was surprised he wasn't picked 1st round

yorgis

me too nostradamus. at least if he had of played another game we could have got his price increase. i'll be trading this for toy and cash in on him later

Mish

Quote from: nostradamus on April 19, 2011, 02:28:01 PM
Quote from: Mish on April 19, 2011, 02:19:39 PM
ouch!!! thats gotta suck!! thats why you dont trade a player in before they have a BE!

l had him from the get go......was surprised he wasn't picked 1st round

i had him as well, but was forced to change for stanley when the teams came out. although i did keep hibberd because james said he would play round 2. big mistake trusting hirdy.

Bluke

First example of the sub rule really screwing a player.

He was off the ground but McKenna had to put him back on because so many Suns were cramping.

http://au.news.yahoo.com/thewest/sport/a/-/afl/9227936/coads-season-in-the-sun-maybe-over/

The AFL should be held responsible for that... It is irresponsible of them only allowing 3 player benches, I dont mind the sub rule (it makes the game more fair). But only having three bench spots puts players well being at risk.

chrisuzz

what are the people that already have Toy gonna do ? :-\

Alex Johnson from Sydney ? Dont know much bout this lad...

nostradamus

Quote from: Bluke on April 19, 2011, 04:30:50 PM
First example of the sub rule really screwing a player.

He was off the ground but McKenna had to put him back on because so many Suns were cramping.

http://au.news.yahoo.com/thewest/sport/a/-/afl/9227936/coads-season-in-the-sun-maybe-over/

The AFL should be held responsible for that... It is irresponsible of them only allowing 3 player benches, I dont mind the sub rule (it makes the game more fair). But only having three bench spots puts players well being at risk.

l understand where the league was coming from, but.......

it was all rather rushed ........ if they only intended having 3 on the bench, then there should have been 2 subs.

The presesnt set up only works well if there is only 1 player injured badly enough not to be able to come back on. However if there are 2 or more then a side is seriously disadvantaged. Which in turn affects player well being, and potentially match results, this probably had a hand in the essendon carlton draw

TMurphBROWNLOW

toy is definitely in the sun's best 22.

i thought it was really rough for him to be dropped after the carlton game. i believe he played well and was efficient once he was subbed on.

Joe Dirt

Iv got 23 trades and 700k in the bank (dont ask why) and goin for league win as im currently ranked 20000th.

Should i actually trade coad or is a waste of a trade as i could just leave that 100k player on the bench? Keeping him until he comes back and is a reserve for when finals comes round. Maybe even goes up enough to trade down/up ...for money/to a premo.

My backline is gibbs enright duff gilbert adcock heppell duigan lower pederson coad