Is This The Dumbest Thing Of My Life So Far?

[hally25547]

I just traded Montagna to Pendlebury and I had no reason too. On a scale of 1 to 10 how stupid was this?

I now have 21 trades left and 150k in the bank. Very annoyed right now.

[Bluke]

thats a 1 hally.
Montagna is an absolute spud

[Footy God]

Probably a 7. Might save you 5-10 points a game. But then again they could average the same. Waste. You dont even avoid any bye weeks.

[Slap]

if you were going to be annoyed with it, why do it in the first place.

Well, Pendles is going well so its not soo bad.  It'd be a good move if monty just reeks this season and averages the 85 or so..  But i doubt that'd happen.  if you can straight swap a rookie to monty at some point, it could be worth it..

But I'm gonna say, Montagna is not going to be on the chopping block for me, for a long while.

[thanme]

Get Montags back later on when his $$ are down and his form is up, then you'll feel heaps better :P

[hally25547]

if you were going to be annoyed with it, why do it in the first place.
Well, Pendles is going well so its not soo bad.  It'd be a good move if monty just reeks this season and averages the 85 or so..  But i doubt that'd happen.  if you can straight swap a rookie to monty at some point, it could be worth it..

But I'm gonna say, Montagna is not going to be on the chopping block for me, for a long while.

good question slap  :-[

the main reason i did it was because i had four missing in the mids with boyd, libba, montagna and bewick. montagan was also doing sh*thouse and pendlebury is on fire. Maybe i might trade montagna in later but as my final two midfielders i want selwood and ablett.

[C-Dogg]

sideways

[Windigo]

-

[Ziplock]

8-9

[Just Clancy]

Why didn't you trade Bewick to Prestia like i'm going to?? I had the exact same players missing...

[Wes Mantooth]

agreed, it could have been another cheaper player... gotta back your premiums in

[blah128]

Had to turn my head onto the side to read this thread...it's so sideways  :P
Anyway...could turn out to be a stroke of genius if Pendles keeps gunning it and Joey keeps dropping in value but I would have stuck with him. There's quite a few Saints who are overdue for big games...hopefully they deliver soon

[Holz]

alot of people will disagree with me, but i would much rather have tags in my team, i think he is a better DTer than pendles. if 1 means good trade and 10 is bad than i wiould give it an 11 of the basis i think you just downgraded.

[Chopps]

on a scale of 1 to stupid  i would say stupid +1

hope it works out for you though

[Ziplock]

honestly, I would prefer pendles over tags, but I think it's ridiculous to sidewards trade them.