who's starting curnow over libba

[me]

?

given that we know that curnow will not be the sub, and i can't see collins coming on to replace him, he should play 4 quarters and pump out a decent score at least

we still don't know whether libba will be the sub or not, so i guess there's less risk in starting curnow now

[Master Q]

Well do you think the Pies will destroy Carlton? If so, Curnow, if not, Libba. Simple.

[Bennyy]

Not necessarily. Curnow could not get near it. Its a coin toss! Ive gone libba. Cant really say why lol. Same with a couple of my other rookie selections just gut feel lol. Either should be okay

[Flame]

Simple...I agree with Q..I've gone Libba

[Juddster5]

for one: Collingwood arent going to smash Carlton, i thought that was pretty obvious. Collingwood wont pay much attention to Curnow so he will probably get some of the ball.

[Flame]

Yeah..it will go close..I hope Curnow gets some points..I need him to fatten..

Libba vs GC could score highly!!

[Master Q]

for one: Collingwood arent going to smash Carlton, i thought that was pretty obvious. Collingwood wont pay much attention to Curnow so he will probably get some of the ball.

Go Blues!

[chrisuzz]

tough decision, but remember Cunrow has scored both his scores against easy opposition, where as libba has played against tougher ;)

[Juddster5]

Why dont people get that just because you get good scores against bad teams doesnt mean you go bad when you come up against a quality team in Collingwood.

[TMurphBROWNLOW]

I've gone both + harris.

but i'd pick curnow this week he's looked real good first two rounds.