what to do with Hibbo?

[pinochio]

Was going all week to trade foley > curnow and yarran > tapscott...

but with Hibberd not being named it has thrown the proverbial spanner in the works....do I still do the trades i planned and keep him for DPP OR keep foley nd trade hibberd for curnow OR get libba for hibbered and foley for curnow but this would give me 3 benched players rd 4 which im not a fan of...

so in summeray -

1) Foley > Curnow AND Yarran > Tapscott
OR
2) Hibberd > Curnow AND Yarran > Tapscott
OR
3) Foley > Curnow AND Hibberd > Libba (...keeping in mind I have bewick and boyd...if bewick is named as an emergency though this will yet again thrown another spanner my way :P and will prob be turned into libba)

[Stocutz]

u need to cut Hibberd loose.

i wouldnt worry to much about 1 week having a loaded bench. keep bewick

[dockerone]

I have a similar dilemma as Hibberd is my only squad member not playing.

Yesterday I had convinced myself that I was going to trade him to Curnow but now I am leaning towards Libba.

I would get rid of Yarran if I was you - he will be waaay too inconsistent, Tappy is looking the goods and as an added bonus has Brisbane and the Suns the nest 2 weeks!!

Option 2

[Slap]

Hibberd is my Link to my back line.. Unfortunately I cannot trade him.  I could put Gibbs, lids and heppell in there, but i'd hav to trading one of those to get curnow/libba.. not worth it.

[pinochio]

with jacobs coming back soon hopefully im not to fussed about trading hibbo out tbh...

I really want tapscott as well though (with lion/suns coming up) lolz....i cant to 3 trades!!!!


arg.....and if bewick isnt named in I/C

....who is better to keep foley or yarran???? (if yarran then i cant get tapscott....)

what to do guys!!!!! :'( :'( :'( :'(

[Red Dirtie]

Just give up! go on stress leave..... ;D

[Slap]

with jacobs coming back soon hopefully im not to fussed about trading hibbo out tbh...

I really want tapscott as well though (with lion/suns coming up) lolz....i cant to 3 trades!!!!


arg.....and if bewick isnt named in I/C

....who is better to keep foley or yarran???? (if yarran then i cant get tapscott....)

what to do guys!!!!! :'( :'( :'( :'(

Just turn foley into Libba/Curnow.  Keep Yarran.  And if you can afford the loss of MPP trade Hibberd for ibba/Curnow.

Don't worry, being different to everyone else could work in your favour.

[boo-yaa]

i'm in the exact same boat and am going to keep foley. with the thought of making him a premium come round 8, pendles will be in.
hibberd to libba, loose my mid def link but my fwd/mid link should cover the mids if need be.
and yaz to tappy, all the way to the bank.

[pinochio]

i think i should get curnow over libba..right? since i have boyd/bewick ...and curnow will rise faster with libba having a bye rd 4....


thinking I REALLY want tapscott so will be going yarran to tapscott and hibberd to curnow......is keeping foley a mistake - its just i want tapscott and want to get rid of hibberd....cant do anything with foley now.


thoughts???

[Windigo]

I'm keeping Hibberd. Why trade him out just to have another player do the same thing...Sitting on the pine.

But if benefits your score well..... ???

[pinochio]

hmm very true windigo.....cause ye hibberd will just be on the bench anyways....


Foley > Curnow AND Yarran > Tapscott


fine trades windigo????

[Windigo]

Foley > Curnow AND Yarran > Tapscott

Hm, how much $$$ in bank and do you have the MAX trades at your disposal????

[pinochio]

i have 7k in bank and have 24 trades.....atm! ;)

[Windigo]

Okay:

Foley-$ 235,900 down to Curnow-$96,400
                           
                           SO
235,900 - 96,400

That would give you 139,500 change, + the $ 7,000.

As for Yarran, I'd keep him.

So where else do you need an upgrade?
                           

[pinochio]

no where really i have a bad feeling about yarran and think his rd 1 score will be norm!

...and i really want tapscott :P


thx for the help what do u think???