Sorry to all but another who to start thread, just a few votes and i'm all good

[elephants]

who should i play on my field this week, just whack in a vote

and also on a side note. harris over bewick, D. swallow and hibberd?

cheers lads and ladettes

[Bluke]

Yes, Harris over those three.

And Lower and Heppell

[LaHug]

No need to apologise! You're a frequent contributor so you deserve your share of feedback.
My gut feeling says Lower then Heppell then McKernan then Stanley then Duigan.
And definitely Harris over those three!

[elephants]

Thanks heaps lads, lower is locked no doubt it's mainly out of McKernan and heppel. Heppel has been good but I reckon that the saints will play a lot more defensive lockdown style.

Thanks for the feedback lads :)

[Hawkahh]

Yes, Harris over those three.

And Lower and Heppell

+ 1

Exactly what I'm doing :)

[Ziplock]

^ heppell, lower, harris.

pretty much the same as Lahug, but duigan in front of mckernan.

[LaHug]

No worries :)
I have a general rule to always go with a rookie that has played two good games than someone who has only played one game. Yes, McKernan's first game was good, but we don't know if it was a one off. Heppell has proven he can score well with 76 and 80.

[LaHug]

^ heppell, lower, harris.

pretty much the same as Lahug, but duigan in front of mckernan.

Surely Duigan against Collingwood is gonna score less than McKernan at home against Freo?

[elephants]

Thanks all :)

I am going with lower, heppel, Harris :)

[stuart6982]

Also in regards to Mckernan...Tippet is back so that may affect his scoring, but then the Porpoise drops out so maybe there wont be much difference to his round 1 performance :P we'll see...
summary of rooks (imo)
backs: Lower, Mckernan, Duigan, Stanley
Mids: Krak, Harris, Libratore, Curnow, Savage
Rucks: Smith, The Brisbane Mac that has played (forget which one)
Forwards: Tapscott, Darling, Matera, Richardson

if that doesnt help in the slightest i apologise

[stuart6982]

and i forgot Heppel in back after Lower :P