will he play most weeks Curnow

Started by Ago97, April 06, 2011, 06:44:41 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Ago97

will he play most weeks???

yes/no answer but if u could say why i would appreciate it!

sorry talking bout curnow

matt1985

Will who play most weeks? I'm either going blind or I just missed the players name your asking about?

soutter

Quote from: matt1985 on April 06, 2011, 06:49:44 PM
Will who play most weeks? I'm either going blind or I just missed the players name your asking about?
+1

thanme


4820

yes, because he is a good player !

Stocutz


elephants

Yes this player will always play as he is a jet and untaggable because no one can see him.

bomberboy0618

oh i get it its a metaphorical term for ur failure to communicate

Slap

Quote from: Stocutz on April 06, 2011, 07:23:49 PM
Quote from: 4820 on April 06, 2011, 07:17:59 PM
yes, because he is a good player !

Baaaaaaaahahahahahaha!!!!

I didn't think that comment warranted that over-the-top response.

My two cents; Curnow will play.  I have seen him the last two rounds and he looks great.  An article published on AFL.com within the last 48 hours also highlights his recognition to play well EVERY week, because the entire carlton midfield is up for rearrangement each week.

BUT, to pick Curnow over Libba?  I'm stil not sure, Libba pumped out 10 tackles or something, he can't do that everyweek surely. 
Before reading everyone's posts about Libba, I was certain about Curnow, but I need to flip a coin or something.

Stocutz

I didnt realise having a laugh could be construde as 'over the top' anyway I hope I don't get a SLAP as punishment haha (sorry couldn't help myself)....

Back on topic. Either libba or Curnow really their both going to make plenty. Libba 1st term against the bombers in his 1st game was sublime if ur thinking e can't do it against good opposition

Stocutz

And I'd say the way he's playing he will play most weeks.

Slap

Quote from: Stocutz on April 06, 2011, 08:40:26 PM
I didnt realise having a laugh could be construde as 'over the top' anyway I hope I don't get a SLAP as punishment haha (sorry couldn't help myself)....

Back on topic. Either libba or Curnow really their both going to make plenty. Libba 1st term against the bombers in his 1st game was sublime if ur thinking e can't do it against good opposition

I don't really care, but i interpret "baha" as a mock.

Have you seen libba play?  Thats the thing holding me back right now, I've seen Curnow twice, and I'm impressed, but I cannot compare.

Bluke

I watched Libba play last week and he was very, very impressive.

bundyboy

unfortunately I saw both guys - Curnow wk1, and he was really good, and then saw Libba wk2, and he was just as bloody good...   I didn't see their "quiet" weeks.

i still am struggling to pick between them, because I can still only get on this week under current plan,....

Stocutz

Quote from: bundyboy on April 06, 2011, 09:03:17 PM
unfortunately I saw both guys - Curnow wk1, and he was really good, and then saw Libba wk2, and he was just as bloody good...   I didn't see their "quiet" weeks.

i still am struggling to pick between them, because I can still only get on this week under current plan,....

I saw libba week 1 were he scored 70odd were the dogs got flogged especially in the middle and 1st quarter he had like 8touches 5-6 centre clearances was phenomenal for a 1st gamer. Then 2nd quarter mcveigh got the shut down role on (what a complement) and barely touched it quarter 2 and like many others didn't do much but was still respectable in a 10goal loss.

Curnow's test is this week.

Hope that help u and slap