Which double trade is better?

[Ago97]

Franklin to Higgins(or someone 380k and under) then Montagna to Swan
or Otten to McKeran then Montagna to Swan?

[Bluke]

Franklin to Higgins(or someone 380k and under) then Montagna to Swan
or Otten to McKeran then Montagna to Swan?

Nothing personal mate but both of those trades are equally terrible.

Dont trade likes for likes. Franklin will have better games, especially against Richmond this weekend. Montagna is a gun whose responsibilities will increase with the lose of Hayes, which will hopefully correspond to bigger DT scores.

McKernans job security is far from garanteeed and otten will be a gun

[Ago97]

well i need swan and my mids are:
Pendles, Bartel, Boyd, Montagna, Harris, Swallow(Savage, Bewick, Buckley)

The saints have the curse and montagna is set to plumit so i think montagna would be best to get rid of for swan

[Bluke]

The boat might have sailed mate.. But I guess if you're willing to burn the trades.

I'd go Franklin Higgins

[madskill55]

well i need swan and my mids are:
Pendles, Bartel, Boyd, Montagna, Harris, Swallow(Savage, Bewick, Buckley)

The saints have the curse and montagna is set to plumit so i think montagna would be best to get rid of for swan

Being honest mate, no one needs any particular player. The right combination of players, with the right decisions will get you the best score at the end of the day. Montagne might plummit but it just means that he will soar higher later on...just gotta ride the high's and low's of the tides and not trade prems. id be happy with montagne as a keeper, so no point in trading him. stick with him and get swan later after round 7 after thier first bye. thats my opinion anyways...

[yorgis]

would'nt trade joey, with lenny out he and nicky dal should share mid responsibilities and increase thier output

[Ago97]

whats the point of getting swan in round 7 when his breakeven now in 80 and montagna is something rediculous like 159

[thornz23]

u got montagna as a keeper so dnt worry about his price fluctuating... he will increase his output 4 sure.. and u got buddy as a keeper as well. every1 knows he has some off weeks but he can pump out huge scores. i would most definitely be leaving both of them alone.

[Ago97]

but i neeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeed swan  :'(

[Windigo]

Franklin to Higgins(or someone 380k and under) then Montagna to Swan
or Otten to McKeran then Montagna to Swan?

WOW




                                                                 ???

[thornz23]

mm u do need swan but u really should have had him at the start. now that u dnt have him the only real option is to wait for ure cash cows to fatten up and get him in at about rd 7/8 or so

[Ago97]

do u think swallow bewick and savage will be anywhere near swan by round 7???

[Ago97]

or should i get rid of buckley and savage for curnow and liba to earn that cash and then get swan later because lenny is out
I am beginning to understand now
but still no convinced on montagna
wouldn't having hayes out mean that an extra tagger can go to montagna???

[thornz23]

no definitely not.. but they will go up in price a fair bit by then. then u downgrade probly 2 of them to other rookies who r hopefully playing and upgrade another rookie to swan.

also taggers normally dnt take joey because he isn't as damaging as goddard and he isn't as affected by the tag as NDS.u could possibly make one of those trades to get a solid cash cow but i dnt think u should do both. Not really sure on Buckley's JS so perhaps consider Buckley to libba.

[Ago97]

ok i think ill get libba for buckley and that will give me a heap more cash by round 7

thanks thornz23