Curnow v Harris ??

[BillMurray]

Who would you guys play as 6th Midfielder?

Curnow - coming off a terrific debut and playing a very weak side but I'm just a tad worried about the sub rule

Harris - his team will likely get belted and may struggle to get much of the footy at all, relying mostly on tackles for points.

At the moment I have Curnow locked in.

any thoughts guys?? cheers

[elephants]

I reckon Harris for the safe 60-80 score or bank on curnow not being subbed and look at a possible 90+ score. Personally I would go with harris

[soutter]

Depends whether u want to play it safe with Harris who i personally think will get 80+ this week...he's good for 15-20 touches and 5-10 tackles imo or risk Curnow been the sub or actually playing the full game but having a bit of a letdown after last week. The joys of dreamteam!

[diddley]

harris. id take experience over 1 game of form.

[Nails]

I'd go Curnow to be honest.

GC are too much of an unknown for me and Carlton like to play keepings off as much as anyone.

[Holz]

I'd go Curnow to be honest.

GC are too much of an unknown for me and Carlton like to play keepings off as much as anyone.

im going harris becasue cunrow is a bit of an unknown, we have seen hariis play and he is proven, that always beats out a 1st gamer for me.

[thatguy]

i see everyone is raving about cunrow but is the memory of mitch robinson not a concern? two years ago scored 110 or so on debut, was dropped in round 4.

smells fishy to me.

[Mish]

4 out of 6 new teams in the afl have won their first game.

i got harris, its his 150th game, their playing at home and carlton isnt all that great on the road + GC midfield is a pretty good one imo.

carlton are deff favourites, but i dont think cunrow will be as good as he was last week, new kids are never consistant.

[BillMurray]

Hey guys, thanks heaps for the feedback so far.

Yeah I've re-evaluated and decided to go with Harris. Hearing that it's his 150th match and given the sub question mark around Curnow is a bit too risky for me to pick him. I'm just gonna let Curnow fatten up nicely on the bench for another week. Getting Ward & Curnow as panic trades before rd 1 is looking good so far  ;)

[me]

harris for safety, his numbers will be inflated by a huge number of tackles