Rate My Team!!!!!

[BuddysBestMan]

hey chaps just wondering how every one went. i got 2164 my self and just wondering if anyone could give me some tips like who to put in for goods.
Def:Goddard,Gibbs,Deledio,Broughton,Grimes,heppel,Duigan (Bench) A Otten,S mckeran, j toy

Mid: (capt)Swan,(Vcapt)Judd,Montanga,(Syd) J kenedy, A krakouer,Conca (Bench) D swallow,D harris, Bewick

Ruck: SandilandsD Hale,  (Bench) Z Smith, Keefe

Forwards:Riewoldt,Franklin,Goodes,Dangerfield,Walker,gamble,(bench) Prestia,Tapscot,Darling

any tips?

[BuddysBestMan]

Gday Chaps just to those who have thought of the concept of the riewoldt mine is Nick

[meow meow]

My advice would be to keep Goodes and not waste a trade for no reason. But we got the same score so my advice has no value.

[Big Ange]

sorry to hear meow i got over 2200 selwood and yarran burnt me could of had tapscott on the field ow well... keep punching


btw i dont know but did buckley play and oww yer his playing next week cheers bud :)

[Gava Magpies101]

team is pretty BAD. U MUST SUCK

[BuddysBestMan]

Mr Gava

Thanks mate but i didn't ask for that sort of criticism. Just wanted some tips and I Beat you in round 1!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Alex7089]

Your team was looking really good....Then I saw Hale :-\
I would bring one of Toy/McKernan on for Duigan. After the pre-season he has had I would be leaning toward McKernan.
I'd bring Harris on for Conca as well, if not then Swallow. Either will outscore him as it looks like Conca might be stuck down back where he won't rack up the possessions we thought he would so looks less attractive as an on field player.

Tapps/Prestia on for Danger/Walker this round (Bye) and you should surpass 2200 pretty easily if things go smoothly.

Backline looks solid enough, standard picks.
Midfield looks very nice.
Rucks look shaky with Hale, would you be better off with Smith on the ground? Might be something to ponder.
I would try and trade him out as soon as you could.
They would be the only early trades for me because everything looks sound, but you will lose a lot of points with Hale ;)

[BuddysBestMan]

Thanks Alex

Great tips, so i put toy on for Duigan because Mckeran has the bye, sub Conca off for either swallow or Harris and switch out my Adelaide forwards for my benches. Put smith on for Hale, gonna wait to see what hale does then see if i need to trade him out or not any ideas who to bring in for him????

[Alex7089]

Hmmm. You might need to double trade as your really don't want to be fiddling with your rucks all year so you really want to go to a prem like Cox, Ryder, Hille or even Jolly.

[BuddysBestMan]

yeah

Was thinking of down grounding goods for rookie then that could bring me some cash and then upgrading for the better ruck man. But im not sure who to switch for goods and which ruckman, considering Cox,Ryder or maybe even Petrie at his low price

[Alex7089]

Hmmm. I wouldn't trade Goodes. He will come good and with the byes/late resting you will want to have plenty of trades in the bank for the back end of the season. Never trade out a prem. You may have to carry Hale for a while. But still for me the first man you want to upgrade. We need to just sit back and wait to see what the rookies do, the more money they make (the quicker) the sooner Hale can go. But remember Don't Panic and trade too early.

[BuddysBestMan]

Forgot to add this tho i will probs wait one more week just see the who are the flukes and who's got great dukes

[Alex7089]

Wise choice ;)
You'd look like a fool if you traded Curnow in, then he scored 20 and got dropped (an example from another thread)

[BuddysBestMan]

Anyone who knows anything about this site please answer. one of my Topics got moved to the front banner is that bad or good or have i just posted something in the wrong place?

[Alex7089]

Just means it is in the wrong place. Got moved to the front bar which is basically just a place where every thought not related to anything goes :P 
It is a great place, you will meet a lot of regulars down there you should wander down and have a chat ;)