The 'Good' call 'Bad' call thread

[charliesheen]

Good
- Taking out Connors from Defence
- Taking out Stevie J and putting in Pavlich

Bad
- Replacing Montagna with Selwood (i guess it happens)

Yet to be seen
- Captaincy on Gibbs instead of Swann
- Selecting Adcock in defense (hope he does well)

[tferrier18]

Good:
No overly great selections yet...Just the standard ones: Godd, riewoldt, Dlids


Bad:
Yarran. Didn't look good against the tag, hopefully he gets more time in the centre to help boost his scores. We'll see
Judd over Gibbs as VC
Atley over Curnow :(


Yet to see:
Everitt
Ward
B.Harvey instead of Stevie J
If Buckley will get more than 2 or 3 games. i didn't select him so I'm hoping he doesn't

[ossie85]

Being stubborn enough to not select Bryce Gibbs at all could come back to haunt me

[enzedder]

Being stubborn enough to not select Bryce Gibbs at all could come back to haunt me

I wasn't going to select him either...had Malceski locked in until his injury. I didn't really want him with finals bye but lack of other options meant he was picked.

[Maca24]

Good:
Picking swan over pendles (IMO)
Picking Stevie J

Bad:
Yarran
Selwood getting KO'd
Ditching Hibberd and getting buckley.

[charliesheen]

Beams (BL) subbed off with hip injury, he was absolutely killing it.
Johnathon brown facial injury

Swapped McKernan (scored 90) for darling, bad move????? 

[Alex7089]

I'd say so, Darling probably won't be a huge scorer.

Good
Mundy - Very happy with him managing 130+ was a point of difference in all my games. Also Went Sidey --> Mundy so :)
Lower - Had him on the ground, stoked with his effort
Dangermouse - Proved he can put on the cape and turn a terrible score into a great one.
Bad
Yarran. Yeah.
Selwood
Buckley on the ground
Gibbs C over Swan.

[Maca24]

I still think dangerfield is a liabilty. 11pts at half time, just proves he does go missing quiet a bit.
Im still glad i didnt get him ;)

[Alex7089]

Yes, but he also proved that he can explode, 101 points in a half of footy.
Also, he went missing because he had to go forward due to the Porps injury. ;)
I'm still glad I got him.

[BoredSaint]

interesting round so far..

good

swapping hibberd for lower last minute and having him on the ground..
getting over my stubborness and picking gibbs
uniquish newman
captain swanny
kraks
solid scores from otten and knights and pav

bad
yarran.

yet to know
cooney
kennedy
hurn
richardson
jamar

all are pretty unique apart from richardson

[Patrician]

Taking out Deledio for Broughton....still not sure if that was a good or bad decision. Time will tell.

Buddy in, Rioli out...kinda the same but I reckon I'm going to lose out on that one.

Very happy with Bartel and Burgoyne.

Think going Pendles over Swan will be my worst call.

[charliesheen]

P.Ryder 133

BARGAIN!  glad i went ryder

J.Watson 140

damn have you guys seen essendons draw, i like it.

[FactHunt]

Bad: Bartel out for Selwood (with some other squeezing... S.Johnson to Dangermouse, not too bad but Selwood's injury is! I doubt he'll travel to perth for this weeks match, anyone heard anything?)
No Swan... what was I thinking, even posted that he was a set and forget type captain... doof!

Good:Loving Krak
Young blokes been good in Heppell, Tapscott, Lower (I know, he's not THAT young, but his price is), even Conca looked promising despite average score.
No LTI's thus far for me fingers crossed XXXXXX


Solid 1st round, without crushing it!

[nathan11]

heppel on the bench :(  glad i started lower, and got ryder, dunno what i was thinking with t walker :)

[charliesheen]

Heppel in my midfield :)

I guess with Selwood possibly out (resting for freo), heppel could start with the gc guys maybe.