C.Judd VS M.Murphy

[Scratchy]

I've got Yarran in DT and SC.
Number 6 draft pick, 3rd season, new higher-scoring role, good pre-season averages (80 in DT, 102 in SC), improving side.

[HotTiges]

mmmmm had that in my head. im just really rushed this yr with SC and Dt. so my sides only doen quickly and that was my last pick.

choice was Judd in the end.

wat do u think of my side now........

Backs - goddard, gibbs, deleido, mackie, otten, heppell, toy              BENCH - Duigan, lower, delaney.L
mids  - swan, judd, selwood, cross, foley, swallow                            BENCH - harris, pittard, hibberd
rucks - cox, trengrove                                                                  BENCH - petrie, smith
forwards - franklin, pav, goodes, higgns, yarran, knight, kreakouer      BENCH - matera, richardson, mckernan

cash - $78,000

What u think????

Pretty good side for a quick pick.. Wouldn't pick Mackie. Not sure he is in Geelong's best 22 but that was going on last year's Prelim. You could upgrade Mackie to a Hurn or Grundy who use the ball better. Mackie more DT I reckon. Rest of it is pretty good. FWDs look a tad risky but good on paper. Heard Jackson Trengove could be playing around HB so could boost his scores also leadership group as well plus you have Petrie to go ruck rest of the year anyways.. I like it.

I though it was good also... might take u up on the mackie decision. ill have to flip a coin for those 2 hahah.

Trengrove will surprise this yr im confident in him and also if that fails like u said i have Petri to pick up the slack hahah

im still not 100% about Yarran, thoughts on him.....

thanks.

Yeah Yarran looks good. Not sure how much he can avg. I can see some real good scores aka round 1 vs Richmond where the Blue boys always score high remember mitch robinson not long ago??? but also some inconsistent scores due to his lack of experience in his new role. I had him in till a couple of days ago. I've already got 2 Blues which is enough for me.

Well yer i was abit the same until i did some research and the reason why i put him in was 1. he will now play down back. 2. his run and carry and breaking lines.. 3. loves a goal or two (so he might push forward against shower sides) ;-)

I was hoping Courtney Dempsey would do something similar last year  :-\

[schezza]

I've got Yarran in DT and SC.
Number 6 draft pick, 3rd season, new higher-scoring role, good pre-season averages (80 in DT, 102 in SC), improving side.

ticked all the right boxes i guess...... hopefully with him down back he can run n carry and have shots at goal on occaions......

[schezza]

mmmmm had that in my head. im just really rushed this yr with SC and Dt. so my sides only doen quickly and that was my last pick.

choice was Judd in the end.

wat do u think of my side now........

Backs - goddard, gibbs, deleido, mackie, otten, heppell, toy              BENCH - Duigan, lower, delaney.L
mids  - swan, judd, selwood, cross, foley, swallow                            BENCH - harris, pittard, hibberd
rucks - cox, trengrove                                                                  BENCH - petrie, smith
forwards - franklin, pav, goodes, higgns, yarran, knight, kreakouer      BENCH - matera, richardson, mckernan

cash - $78,000

What u think????

Pretty good side for a quick pick.. Wouldn't pick Mackie. Not sure he is in Geelong's best 22 but that was going on last year's Prelim. You could upgrade Mackie to a Hurn or Grundy who use the ball better. Mackie more DT I reckon. Rest of it is pretty good. FWDs look a tad risky but good on paper. Heard Jackson Trengove could be playing around HB so could boost his scores also leadership group as well plus you have Petrie to go ruck rest of the year anyways.. I like it.

I though it was good also... might take u up on the mackie decision. ill have to flip a coin for those 2 hahah.

Trengrove will surprise this yr im confident in him and also if that fails like u said i have Petri to pick up the slack hahah

im still not 100% about Yarran, thoughts on him.....

thanks.

Yeah Yarran looks good. Not sure how much he can avg. I can see some real good scores aka round 1 vs Richmond where the Blue boys always score high remember mitch robinson not long ago??? but also some inconsistent scores due to his lack of experience in his new role. I had him in till a couple of days ago. I've already got 2 Blues which is enough for me.

Well yer i was abit the same until i did some research and the reason why i put him in was 1. he will now play down back. 2. his run and carry and breaking lines.. 3. loves a goal or two (so he might push forward against shower sides) ;-)

I was hoping Courtney Dempsey would do something similar last year  :-\

HAHA C.Dempsey, i don't really rate him at all to be honest..... you think hurn will have a good season....??? his averages for SC in pre-season 2011 were, 70 72 51 as to grundy, 92 111 115......... however i do save some cash taking Hurn but might lose points..... decisions decisions.!

[HotTiges]

mmmmm had that in my head. im just really rushed this yr with SC and Dt. so my sides only doen quickly and that was my last pick.

choice was Judd in the end.

wat do u think of my side now........

Backs - goddard, gibbs, deleido, mackie, otten, heppell, toy              BENCH - Duigan, lower, delaney.L
mids  - swan, judd, selwood, cross, foley, swallow                            BENCH - harris, pittard, hibberd
rucks - cox, trengrove                                                                  BENCH - petrie, smith
forwards - franklin, pav, goodes, higgns, yarran, knight, kreakouer      BENCH - matera, richardson, mckernan

cash - $78,000

What u think????

Pretty good side for a quick pick.. Wouldn't pick Mackie. Not sure he is in Geelong's best 22 but that was going on last year's Prelim. You could upgrade Mackie to a Hurn or Grundy who use the ball better. Mackie more DT I reckon. Rest of it is pretty good. FWDs look a tad risky but good on paper. Heard Jackson Trengove could be playing around HB so could boost his scores also leadership group as well plus you have Petrie to go ruck rest of the year anyways.. I like it.

I though it was good also... might take u up on the mackie decision. ill have to flip a coin for those 2 hahah.

Trengrove will surprise this yr im confident in him and also if that fails like u said i have Petri to pick up the slack hahah

im still not 100% about Yarran, thoughts on him.....

thanks.

Yeah Yarran looks good. Not sure how much he can avg. I can see some real good scores aka round 1 vs Richmond where the Blue boys always score high remember mitch robinson not long ago??? but also some inconsistent scores due to his lack of experience in his new role. I had him in till a couple of days ago. I've already got 2 Blues which is enough for me.

Well yer i was abit the same until i did some research and the reason why i put him in was 1. he will now play down back. 2. his run and carry and breaking lines.. 3. loves a goal or two (so he might push forward against shower sides) ;-)

I was hoping Courtney Dempsey would do something similar last year  :-\

HAHA C.Dempsey, i don't really rate him at all to be honest..... you think hurn will have a good season....??? his averages for SC in pre-season 2011 were, 70 72 51 as to grundy, 92 111 115......... however i do save some cash taking Hurn but might lose points..... decisions decisions.!

Yeah after watching him last year he went worse then backwards.. almost Masten like. I'm going Reg but Hurn is a decent pick..

[schezza]

mmmmm had that in my head. im just really rushed this yr with SC and Dt. so my sides only doen quickly and that was my last pick.

choice was Judd in the end.

wat do u think of my side now........

Backs - goddard, gibbs, deleido, mackie, otten, heppell, toy              BENCH - Duigan, lower, delaney.L
mids  - swan, judd, selwood, cross, foley, swallow                            BENCH - harris, pittard, hibberd
rucks - cox, trengrove                                                                  BENCH - petrie, smith
forwards - franklin, pav, goodes, higgns, yarran, knight, kreakouer      BENCH - matera, richardson, mckernan

cash - $78,000

What u think????

Pretty good side for a quick pick.. Wouldn't pick Mackie. Not sure he is in Geelong's best 22 but that was going on last year's Prelim. You could upgrade Mackie to a Hurn or Grundy who use the ball better. Mackie more DT I reckon. Rest of it is pretty good. FWDs look a tad risky but good on paper. Heard Jackson Trengove could be playing around HB so could boost his scores also leadership group as well plus you have Petrie to go ruck rest of the year anyways.. I like it.

I though it was good also... might take u up on the mackie decision. ill have to flip a coin for those 2 hahah.

Trengrove will surprise this yr im confident in him and also if that fails like u said i have Petri to pick up the slack hahah

im still not 100% about Yarran, thoughts on him.....

thanks.

Yeah Yarran looks good. Not sure how much he can avg. I can see some real good scores aka round 1 vs Richmond where the Blue boys always score high remember mitch robinson not long ago??? but also some inconsistent scores due to his lack of experience in his new role. I had him in till a couple of days ago. I've already got 2 Blues which is enough for me.

Well yer i was abit the same until i did some research and the reason why i put him in was 1. he will now play down back. 2. his run and carry and breaking lines.. 3. loves a goal or two (so he might push forward against shower sides) ;-)

I was hoping Courtney Dempsey would do something similar last year  :-\

HAHA C.Dempsey, i don't really rate him at all to be honest..... you think hurn will have a good season....??? his averages for SC in pre-season 2011 were, 70 72 51 as to grundy, 92 111 115......... however i do save some cash taking Hurn but might lose points..... decisions decisions.!

Yeah after watching him last year he went worse then backwards.. almost Masten like. I'm going Reg but Hurn is a decent pick..

hahahaahahahahh

now i have to make my last tough decision i tihnk... whos reg?

[Scratchy]

Reg is Grundy.

[simma1978]

Getting back to the topic on hand which was meant to be Judd vs Murphy - thanks for the Trengove tangent lads!

I think that Murphy will be a better choice this year. Murphy has had a better pre season than Judd and he uses the ball more efficiently. Judd really isn't going to get any better where as Murphy has plenty of improvement left in him. For Carlton to go to the next level guys like Murphy have to lift which I think he will. Futhermore, most people will go for Judd and Murphy will be a unique pick - Murphy for me.

[burner11]

Judd in SC Murphy in DT