Harris vs D.Swallow

[footynut10]

I was just wondering, is it really necessary to have both of these guys
im definitely keeping harris but now starting to reconsider having dswallow aswell

what do you guys think??

[bluedreamin]

I'm having doubts about Swallow... I just wish he had shown a little bit more in the pre-season. Along with McKenna saying he will probably get about a dozen games this year I am starting to look elsewhere. I guess at his price (and on the back of all the hype) I was expecting him to play the majority of the season.

Harris is a mature body and I would expect him to be there all year. And he's cheaper. So if I were forced to choose I'd have to go Harris.

[scotty_222]

you need both

[bomberboy0618]

ok i have it under good authority (someone who has played against them) that harris will play most of the time and score slightly less than swallow. Get both.

[footynut10]

ok fair enough, but isn't anyone worried about swallow getting tagged??
where harris will go under the radar, and you'd think he will average the same as swallow if not more

[HotTiges]

ok fair enough, but isn't anyone worried about swallow getting tagged??
where harris will go under the radar, and you'd think he will average the same as swallow if not more

Not sure how much Swallow will get tagged. You have the great one and Rishca to worry about firstly. I think Swallow will score similar to Martin last year which was very handy. Harris will be handy as well. Why not have both?

[footynut10]

i see your point.
but i think its a bit of a risk starting both of them on the field, dont you?

[bomberboy0618]

i see your point.
but i think its a bit of a risk starting both of them on the field, dont you?

yes but to borrow a phrase
"you gotta risk it to get to the biscuit"

[scotty_222]

i wouldnt start both.. they have a bye first up
id be using em as cash cows

[Luigi197]

They are both really hard to miss.

Harris is a must given his experience and price.
D Swallow is an absolute gun, though Conca, Polec and Gaff all compete for a spot against him in your team at that similar price.

[meow meow]

Bennell will be better than the pair of them.

[Boomz]

Harris is a must because of his experience & durability. Swallow isn't quite as much of a must have but I'll get him I think...

[simma1978]

I'm having doubts about Swallow... I just wish he had shown a little bit more in the pre-season. Along with McKenna saying he will probably get about a dozen games this year I am starting to look elsewhere. I guess at his price (and on the back of all the hype) I was expecting him to play the majority of the season.

Harris is a mature body and I would expect him to be there all year. And he's cheaper. So if I were forced to choose I'd have to go Harris.

How gullible are you? Swallow will play most games!!!!!Mckenna didn't say he'll play 12 games, he said he would be happy if he played 12 games - big difference. Baring injuries, I'll eat my hat if he only plays 12 games!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[bomberboy0618]

He wont play the whole season but will play most as they have to rotate youngsters to blood as many as possible

[Alex7089]

In a team as young as this Swallow will probably establish himself as someone who is too important in the team to leave out...Like Martin last year.

I'm personally leaving Swallow out. Harris is cheaper and more durable.
I want Polec more so I have gone with him...