Franklin or nick riewoldt

[camewill]

Who is better?

[yorgis]

6 of 1 1/2 dozen of the other [either or, if you can get both better]

[diddley]

roo, every day of the week.

[valkorum]

Buddy has the potential to score bigger scores than Roo but he normally misses a few games each year due to suspension.

[Rusty00]

Will average about the same IMO. Deciding factor could be what other players you have in your team, to try and limit the damage from the Round 4 or Round 6 bye (if you're going for overall that is).

[Fletch74]

Buddy has the potential to score bigger scores than Roo but he normally misses a few games each year due to suspension.

Roo, I believe would also be more consistent than Buddy

[Swallow12]

Buddy, but id get both

[Usman]

Roo JUST due to consistency

[tkringle]

I just went through this.. ended up going Roo but only because i already had Rioli in the forward line

[enzedder]

Riewoldt

[Samm79]

Buddy has the potential to score bigger scores than Roo but he normally misses a few games each year due to suspension.

x2 I think a player who plays more games per year is an underated quality.

[meow meow]

Roo will play more, and average more. Put money on him to win the Coleman too.

[burner11]

6 of 1 1/2 dozen of the other [either or, if you can get both better]

+1

[burner11]

Buddy has the potential to score bigger scores than Roo but he normally misses a few games each year due to suspension.

x2 I think a player who plays more games per year is an underated quality.

Buddy had an average year last year and still scored well so if he goes off this year he will kill it !!!

[bjrouse]

Both but Roo if you can only have one