judd vs selwood

[fever]

judd. i'm waiting to see how selwood handles the no 1 tag now.

[burner11]

Judd then upgrade Selwood into your side by mid year

[lado]

i would go judd. hes an out and out gun. plus alot of people out there  are still unsure if selwood will increase his scoring with ablett gone. but they are both good and you cant go wrong

Selwoods ave of 117.8 not enough.......... Scored 5th most last year.......


True though - they are both good - cannot go wrong!!!!

[yorgis]

why would you even consider it a waste of a trade, to trade out juddy or selwood just b4 the finals ? you dont reckon consistent performers like those 2 are worth 1 trade? i can just about guarantee u they won't go down in price, and come finals time, 1 trade and u can get just about anyone u want

[Usman]

What is the highest you have finished overall Usman?

Definately not a win!!!!!  ;D but its a simple concept you look at all the teams that have won it in the past they pick players they think will score the most and it pays off. Who cares if Judd and Selwood have a bye late in the season so be it! all players have 2 byes. You can say that getting players after they have there early byes is an acvantage but dont forget you have missed all their points in the mean time.

[burner11]

My thought is to win your semi. final as to skip playin the prelim. when Carlton have the bye ;-)

[Scratchy]

My thought is to win your semi. final as to skip playin the prelim. when Carlton have the bye ;-)

I don't think it works that way. I would have thought you win your Qualifying Final so you skip the Semi (when Geelong have a bye) and then you still have to play the Prelim.
I have Judd and Selwood, a bit worried that Selwood's scores might dip but I'm not going to trade him in so I may as well start with him in and trade in the Saints and Dogs players later (who don't miss finals).