which carlton midfielder?

corzer · March 14, 2011, 12:58:37 PM

which carlton midfielder would be better out of gibbs, murphy and simpson?

littleblueboy2906 · March 14, 2011, 01:00:18 PM

Judd

corzer · March 14, 2011, 01:22:35 PM

to get judd id have to downgrade higgins to knights is this a good idea though?

eagles929406 · March 14, 2011, 01:58:16 PM

none, dont see the value in getting them or essendon considering the byes in rnd 23/24 dont want any missing that time of year for overall or league victories

Swallow12 · March 14, 2011, 02:00:27 PM

Gibbs (MPP), then Murphy, then Judd

diddley · March 14, 2011, 02:19:12 PM

i have gibbs in the back, and murphy in the middle. simpson would be a great smokie though. flies way under the radar with all the attention going to judd murph and gibbs.

diddley · March 14, 2011, 02:19:43 PM

*sorry, when i said smokie, i meant unique.

Usman · March 14, 2011, 06:54:21 PM

in terms of avg Judd JUST over murphy by a couple of points
in terms of team balance Gibbs cause he has dpp
in terms of consistency Murphy is just an out and out gun 100+ every week

so go with your gut you cant go wrong with any of them i have gibbs and murphy gibbs in backs and murphy in mids obviously

meow meow · March 14, 2011, 07:17:52 PM

Murphy played 2010 with OP, which he is free of now. Top notch ball user. Get on him.

Judd is going to be an injury prone old man soon, with the distraction of his soon to be milf wife having a baby.

Gibbs is Gibbs. If there is some cheap possessions on offer then he'll be all over them.

diddley · March 15, 2011, 06:11:30 AM

Quote from: meow meow on March 14, 2011, 07:17:52 PM
Murphy played 2010 with OP, which he is free of now. Top notch ball user. Get on him.

Judd is going to be an injury prone old man soon, with the distraction of his soon to be milf wife having a baby.

Gibbs is Gibbs. If there is some cheap possessions on offer then he'll be all over them.

1. true
2. maybe not all true this year. he isnt shane woewodin. give it a couple more years for his rapid decline. if he will drop, it wont be by much.
3. true.

Big Ange · March 15, 2011, 10:29:10 PM

JUDD YOU DUD

djhar9 · March 16, 2011, 03:24:46 PM

imo Murph will average more but Gibbs has MPP. However, at Murph's price you could pick up another midfielder whos just as good but will play come finals time.

Gibbs for mine.

YOUNGTELLICA · March 16, 2011, 05:04:26 PM

Gibbs in the BAC, Murphy in the MID. Judd pulls out the occassional 60's/70's - Murphy is an 85+ lock week in week out, just doesn't get the 140's Judd can.

Usman · March 16, 2011, 05:05:36 PM

I reckon Murphy will get 140+ scores this year though so he is in for me.

djhar9 · March 16, 2011, 05:27:44 PM

Quote from: YOUNGTELLICA on March 16, 2011, 05:04:26 PM
Gibbs in the BAC, Murphy in the MID. Judd pulls out the occassional 60's/70's - Murphy is an 85+ lock week in week out, just doesn't get the 140's Judd can.

Lies, I don't reckon Judd pulled one score below 90 last season and that would have been once or twice max if at all.