brodie smith vs nick duigan vs matthew watson vs simon bucklet

[Magpie77]

which player and why??

[MightyLions]

Duigan is safest bet, but watson is more unique, but they won't be really on your field, just earning you cash so go with Duigan, no need for uniqueness in this circumstance!

[yorgis]

buckley showed a bit last night

[meow meow]

Reid + Tarrant + Toovey + Shaw + Maxwell + O'Brien + Davis/Goldsack = No Room for Buckley.

Smith will score the most of of all these, so if he's in for round 1 then get on.

[MightyLions]

Had never heard of smith up until this thread, if you already have otten definately get Duigan!

[H1bb3i2d]

Duigans your safest bet, but smith has the highest scoring potential. Watson won't score as high as duigan imo, and Buckley is too far down collingwoods list to get many games, especially early with little to no injuries for the pies.

[Johnnysd]

smith acl?

[HotTiges]

smith acl?

Think it was Brodie Martin just quietly..

[CrowsFan]

Yeah john that was Brodie Martin who did the acl.
Surprised you haven't heard of smith mightylions he was pick 14 in the draft last year. Should score highly when played but not sure how much game time he will get...

[bmac25]

Duigan for mine.  Mature age rookie will play round 1 and should play most games.  Buckley could be helped by Maxwells injury (4 weeks) but I doubt it, he's too far down the pecking order.  Otherwise maybe Smith...maybe.  Who's this Watson bloke anyway?

[FactHunt]

smith acl?

Think it was Brodie Martin just quietly..

he got the all clear

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/no-knee-operation-for-brodie-martin/story-e6frf9jf-1226017195131

[CrowsFan]

Thank you FactHunt you have made my day ;D
He is one of my favourite players!

[FactHunt]

Thank you FactHunt you have made my day ;D
He is one of my favourite players!

no probs... yeah i like the way he goes about it too :D

[HotTiges]

looks like he could play a bit..