Rate my team

Started by walshy1369, March 02, 2011, 01:32:31 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

walshy1369

Have gone for a fairly common backline, although i have tried to mix the rest of it up with some unique players. Please cooment and i will comment on yours.
Cheers

Backs: GIBBS, DELEDIO, DUFFIELD, GRIMES, ADCOCK, LAIDLER, OTTENS Bench: Stanley, Toy, Duigan

Midfield: MONTAGNA, PENDLEBURY, J. COREY, ANTHONY, COTCHIN, HEPPELL Bench: Swallow, Harris, Mzungu

Rucks: COX, FRASER Bench: Petrie, Z.Smith

Forwards: REIWOLDT, DIDAK, HIGGINS, ZAHARAKIS, KNIGHTS, GAMBLE, KRAKEOUR Bench: Richardson, Prestia, Callinan <Player 8, Player 9, Player 10>

Cash Left: 243,000

yorgis

too many players coming back from injury- adcock,dids higgs, knights. i would downgrade adcock to hibberd ,mpp, wait and see with dids or swap with buddy or rioli,and upgrade zaha to stevie j or pav. sorry cant work out cash but my comps running slow.

someguy

First thing I notice is that you're missing the 3 most commonly picked players: Goddard, Swan and Franklin. There's a strong chance that these 3 players will be in the top 10 scoring this year so I do find it interesting that they have been omitted from your team. Obviously the upside of this is that it gives you a unique team with the likes of Laidler (interesting pick), Pendlebury, Corey, Cotchin, and Fraser. Not sold on Didak given his interrupted pre-season - maybe bring in buddy for him?

Also alot of money on your bench (Petrie and Swallow) and in the bank (assume you're going for the league win?). While this does give you freedom to move early in the season with trades, it has limited the number of premiums/keepers in your team; by my count you have 12 premiums/keepers (Gibbs, Deledio, Duffield, Grimes, Montagna, Pendlebury, Corey, Anthony, Cox, Riewoldt, Didak, Higgins) which is a little down on most teams who typically have around 14/15. This means that you'll be burning more trades than most teams in order maximise your teams potential. You also need to take into account injuries that will inevitably happen - especially given the number of players you have coming back from injury or who are injury prone - adcock, otten, didak, higgins, kinghts, corey, anthony, cotchin, grimes and cox.

Overall unique team, but I like it: 7/10