Rate My SC out of 10

[Magpie77]

Starting 22:

Defenders:
Brendon Goddard | Bryce Gibbs | Brett Deledio | Greg Broughton | Jack Grimes | Andy Otten | Dyson Heppell

Karmichael Hunt | Nicholas Duigan | Paul Puopolo

Midfielders:
Dane Swan | Joel Selwood | Marc Murphy | Liam Anthony | Andrew Gaff | Jared Polec

David Swallow | Daniel Harris | Ian Callinhan

Ruckmen:
Aaron Sandilands | Darren Jolly

Robert Campbell | Tom Redricx

Forwards:
Paul Chapman | Nick Riewoldt | Lance Franklin | Shaun Higgins | Andrew Krakouer | Tendai Mzungu | Cameron Richardson

Brandon Matera | Isaac Smith | Jack Darling

$50,000 left   ;D

Callinhan or Hibberd??

Thanks in advance.

[Nathans Brawlers]

Back: Hunt is a no no. Apart from that it a solid backline.

Mid: Swallow and Harris can both be starters , i would dongrade Gaff or Polec or even both and free up some cash then start Swallow and Harris. Once again apart from that, solid.

Rucks : Same as everyone else pretty much , cant go rong.

Forwards : I dont think Chapman will score badly but Geelong have a bye in SC finals witch means you will have to trade him if you make finals. If you were to downgrade him to Pavlich or maybe Slyvia then you might be able to upgrade Darling to a mid price player.

7/10

[Big Ange]

9 out of 10

chappy i would trade for rolli i dont know about chappy this year karmichael hunt got to be serious others better than him!!!the rest of the team looks good

[Magpie77]

9 out of 10

karmichael hunt got to be serious others better than him!!!

for 100K to have him in your reserves there isn't really any downside

[Big Ange]

polac out for hibbard
chappy out for rolioi/pav/goodes
karmichael hunt out for toy/ d standley

[Big Ange]

ur banking on someone who hasnt any afl experience.... look its ur team i personaly think daniel standly is a better fit his preveious year in the vfl was excellent and nab was good too

[Nathans Brawlers]

Thats true he is only about 100k but why have him if there are other players around the same price that are better , will score more and make more money?

[Big Ange]

Thats true he is only about 100k but why have him if there are other players around the same price that are better , will score more and make more money?

excactly!!!

[Magpie77]

Thats true he is only about 100k but why have him if there are other players around the same price that are better , will score more and make more money?

but will they play every single game??

[Nathans Brawlers]

depends on who you pick , and they will be on your bench so doesnt really mater, they will get traded aswell.

[Big Ange]

depends on who you pick , and they will be on your bench so doesnt really mater, they will get traded aswell.

true but u want ur bench players playing too making the cash

[Big Ange]

Karmichael Hunt will he play every game?? who knows... is he fit enough i dunno i wouldnt buy a guy who hasnt played afl footy before but its ur team and who knows he might prove me and lot of people wrong

[Nathans Brawlers]

when i say doesnt really mater i mean like if they dont play the end game it doesnt mater because you will have them traded already and be making money

[ELLsendon]

8/10

[FactHunt]

Overall i think the team is quite solid. My main criticism would be that byes haven't been properly accounted for... you have 4 guys that 'probably' should be out of the team come sc finals time: in Selwood, Chappy, Gibbs and Murphy. (unless you win the first round and skip the next (in league only), but would still miss out for overall). I think that having a couple of these guys is important for scoring purposes throughout the year, but 4 would be a worry IMO to move out for sideways trades later on.