Boyd vs Bartel

[cledus32]

I want to bring Pav into my mids to use his MPP, But i have Swan, Boyd, Gibbs, Bartel in there, who has to go (also want to use Gibbs' MPP, so he needs to stay)

[yorgis]

having the same problem myself. i would like to have 2 mid/for mpp's and 2 mid/back mpp's. have swan, joey,hodge,cornes mzungu,heppel  [polec,swallow, harris] . do'nt really want to change anyone [can't find anyone i prefer anyway] so i guess you can't have your cake and eat it too, nor have the best of both worlds

[ossie85]

I've struggled with those two myself. I think Boyd will give a great consistency though, and Bartel has had an interrupted (though relatively minor) preseason.

I'd also like to have Selwood in my team at one point, so I'd go with Boyd

[Alex7089]

Go with Boyd. Consistent and durable.
Like Ossie said although it was minor his pre-season was interrupted.

A few question marks with Bartel, both with injury and how GAJ leaving will affect his scoring.

[j959]

keep Boyd and Bartel and leave Pav in the fwds!  ;)

but seriously, if i had to lose one, i'd lose Boyd (for SC anyway) - if it were DT, i'd go the other way round ...