unique or bad pick.

Started by ando_10, February 24, 2011, 02:41:06 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

ando_10

thinking of brodie martin from the crows aparently neil craig rates him highly will he play much this year?

tferrier18

hes a good player, will probably score well and play 15+ games but he's too expensive to take the risk into the unknown.

DG

Quote from: tferrier18 on February 24, 2011, 02:45:24 PM
hes a good player, will probably score well and play 15+ games but he's too expensive to take the risk into the unknown.

Kinda agree, but depending on his role, could average 85+, in that case could be worth a shot. Im not tho

Crushemall

At just under $300K I think there are is a few options although Brodie Martin is right up there with these guys:

C.Bird(Syd), M.White (Ric), S.Crameri (Ess), D.Ellard (Car), C.Masten (Wes).

At the end of the day you can't go wrong with Martin.

tferrier18

Don't choose masten.

He tears it up on the track every pre-season but then once he starts playing he never scores well. He kicks way too many clangers and is much more suited to DT than SC.

Crushemall

Quote from: tferrier18 on February 24, 2011, 03:31:47 PM
Don't choose masten.

He tears it up on the track every pre-season but then once he starts playing he never scores well. He kicks way too many clangers and is much more suited to DT than SC.

Thanks for the heads up does DT not recognise clangers or mis directed kicks?

tferrier18

In dt a kick is counted as 3 points whether it is a clanger, misdirected or spot on. A kick is a kick and a handball is a handball

troy87

I currently have him in my side as he is 80k cheaper than Anthony and has the ability to average 85+.

So far he has done well off the HB Flank in the pre season and there is a couple of spots there up for grabs with no Goodwin or Mcleod.

If he is not selected R1 then i will change him but i'm confident he is in the crows best 22.


diddley

i wouldnt say he is a bad pick. not for me, as i have otten and maybe smith in the backs, but certainly will be sorta unique.