Gia 0r Pav (Rollercoaster or Consistency)

[Windigo]

I can only afford either of these two.

Thoughts?

[dylsta05]

deffs pav, if he plays foward all game his a lock

[chatters24]

Im not overly keen on either. Pav's role is continually up in the air, and as for gia, anyone who has paid any attention to DT the last couple of years will surely know that his consistency will give you greys!

[Mish]

well ive got pav in my team, gia killed me last year with his inconsistancy!

[popedelio]

well ive got pav in my team, gia killed me last year with his inconsistancy!

Why all the hate on Gia? I have Gia and he is a beast, so who cares if he gets a few 70s, he also gets a few 150s ;)

[Plastic Boy]

if youre after someone who gets a few 70's and a few 150's I'd go with Stevie J...He'll be more consistent this year IMO

I think we'll all be surprised with Geelong this year. I think they'll be more creative with roles and the fitness seems to be better with these guys..

Josh Hunt played midfield on the weekend for example of role changes....

Stevie J played everywhere and dominated. 

[LF]

i think it`s a tough call gia scored well on the weekend but he appeared to be playing more in the midfield which is where he got some of those awesome scores last year.pav if he is playing forward scores great but tends to score less playing midfield.i had both last year and to tell you the truth they both annoyed the crap out of me.
i`m keeping my eye on the next few weeks to see where each of them looks likely to be playing the most this season.
i`m also looking at stevie j he appeared everywhere on the weekend and if he continues that he could be a good pickup.

[Windigo]

Yeah, I've ousted both.  ;)