Seaby or Petrie!!

[MercsPower]

why not pick seaby as a 2nd ruck, he performed quite well and could well be a better scorer than petrie! what are your thoughts

[chadburger]

Shh don't tell everyone my secret.

[n4cr123]

i can't believe how many people are jumping of Petrie after 1 Game... Wow... at least he might be a unique now :P

[Windigo]

Seaby has never been a great DT player.

Don't fall for the trap. He was playing against inexperienced rucks (Fraser=Old)

[bb2811]

Seaby - especially if mummy is out - not too many other realistic options @200K

[Holz]

was petrie really that bad, i didnt get to see the game and i can only see the scores from 1 of the roos games.

what did he score in both and why is everyone jumping off him?.

[Hoggy]

Petrie > Seaby any day of the week. Was so frustrating seeing him play at the eagles, thank god they got rid of him when they did... I can't imagine having to support him in my dreamteam aswell!

[SydneyRox]

As a Sydney supporter I would say be careful of making too many conclusions on Seaby after one game.

The worst trade I made last year (and I wasnt alone) was Seaby in after his first couple of games.

I am also surprised at how many people are jumping off Petrie so soon!!

But at the end of the day you can have both... Seaby as your second ruck and Petrie in the fwds if you like the look of both