Duffield vs. Broughton - Please vote

[H1bb3i2d]

^Says it all. And could you also post why? Ta.

[Purple 77]

A tough decision, but i think broughton, he just seems to get the bigger and more consistent scores than duffield, but only just

[H1bb3i2d]

Who'll spend more time in the middle?? Duffield seemed to more last year, but with the recruitment of mzungu, it looked like broughton was going to be released more often... Even trained with the mids a bit I heard... Then hayden's injury...

[Crushemall]

I have a better one Bruce or Broughton

[dylsta05]

broughton for sc and duffy for dt, broughton more efficentive and duffman gets more possi's

[HillHero13]

duffman averaged more in SC last year than DT dylsta?

i got Duffield for the cheaper option, but Broughton for more saftey.

[dylsta05]

broughton - 98.6

duffield - 90.7

i think you are looking else where

[HillHero13]

i didnt mean that.

you were saying Duffman was more DT, and i was saying he averaged more SC than DT, so he is more SC?

but i stay firm with my decision to pick him.

but it's better to be safe than sorry.

[Magpie77]

i would pick broughton for his consistency but if you wanted to save a few bucks duffis the option for you

[dylsta05]

i wasnt debating about duffield dt vs sc, i was saying broughton if better for SC, i never said duffs better at sc then dt?? i was discussing the topic and i said broughton for sc and duff for dt, by that i mean duff better the broughton at dt and likewise

[HillHero13]

ok now i realise what your point is.


But the way you said it just sounded like you were saying that Duffy was more of a DT player, but both are good options.



so mate go with your gut, which should be Broughton, more consistant.

[dylsta05]

ok now i realise what your point is.


But the way you said it just sounded like you were saying that Duffy was more of a DT player, but both are good options.



so mate go with your gut, which should be Broughton, more consistant.

dont worry about it :), yeah broughton IMO

[dmac07]

Broughton, the poll results say it all!