the taylor walker trade thread

[CODYJ]

who should i trade walker for? need cash for skippy to gia trade!

1. macaffer- not sold on his position in the best 22 at collingwood
2. grant- risky pick because of his ability to produce sub-30 scores
3. ballantyne- risking him getting re-injured between now and his estimated round 8 return

anyone ive missed? post your thoughts!

[Cutty]

your pic looks like Thomas is offering up a gobby, you should change it

[Prospector_1]

Yup, so I'd have Thomas for Walker!

[yogibbear]

none of the above? unless ballantyne plays 2 games and averages 50+...

otherwise keep walker.

[Prospector_1]

I reckon Walker's still making money, and as long as I've got 22 on the field, he's not yet ripe.

[thursty]

ben warren?

[Chief Runs With Beer]

See folks - this separates the men from the boys.

Why use a trade on a player Adelaide will persist on for 22 games this season, for three guys likely to weave in and out of the Seniors?

You've got three choices, and you already have presented doubts about each of them. Usually this should cue the lightbulb flashing over your head that you should not be trading!

As for your analysis on Jarrad Grant - how does he boast an "ability to produce sub-30 scores" when he has played once?

Finally - anyone daring to double-trade in a week better get something worthwhile: an elite premium. If your final product is Skipworth > Giansiracusa, that's two trades down the toilet.

Heck, FWIW, Skipworth is probably on level terms with Gia.

In summary - you, my friend, are struggling!